JournalLicensing

Minimum annual royalty: how it works and how to negotiate it

Minimum annual royalty in a technology license: how the shortfall payment works, a worked rupee example, TDS and the terms an Indian MSME should negotiate.

By Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP 7 min read

Part of the guide Licensing technology from Indian institutions: the complete guide for companies

Short answer

A minimum annual royalty is the smallest royalty a licensee must pay the licensor each year, whatever its sales. If royalty earned on sales falls short, the licensee pays the difference as a shortfall payment. A licensee earning ₹3 lakh of royalty against a ₹5 lakh minimum pays ₹2 lakh more.

A minimum annual royalty, sometimes called a minimum guaranteed royalty, is a floor on what a licensee pays each year. You pay a running royalty on sales as usual. If that royalty comes to less than the agreed minimum, you pay the gap. In a strong year, the minimum costs you nothing extra. In a weak year, or a year with no sales at all, it is the whole bill.

The clause exists because a running royalty puts all the sales risk on the licensor. A university or lab that grants you a licence, especially an exclusive one, cannot license the same technology to someone else who might sell more. The minimum is how it makes sure the technology is being used.

How does the shortfall payment work?

The calculation is simple, and it happens at the end of each licence year:

  1. Work out the running royalty earned on the year's sales, at the agreed rate.
  2. Compare it with the minimum annual royalty for that year.
  3. If the royalty earned is lower, pay the difference within the agreed number of days.

Some agreements collect the minimum in advance, at the start of each year, and then credit it against royalty as sales come in. Either way, the total for the year is the larger of the two numbers.

Illustration: a ₹5 lakh minimum in a weak year

₹5 lakh paid for the year
60%40%
Royalty earned on sales₹3 lakh at 3% on ₹1 crore60%
Shortfall payment₹2 lakh top-up to reach the minimum40%
Invented figures, to show the method.

Why do licensors ask for it?

Three reasons come up in almost every negotiation.

  • Exclusivity has a cost. With an exclusive licence, the owner gives up every other licensee. A minimum makes sure that choice earns something.
  • It tests commitment. A company willing to commit to a floor is more likely to invest in production and sales.
  • It funds patent upkeep. Universities pay renewal fees on licensed patents every year, as our guide to patent renewal in India explains. A minimum royalty covers that cost even before sales start.

Public institutions also write other protections into their agreements. ICMR's 2024 Guidelines for Technology Development Collaboration set a royalty of 2% of net sales in its licensing model, and allow termination for failing to reach agreed milestones, for non-payment of royalty for three consecutive reporting periods, or if the company stops manufacturing the product for more than a year. A minimum royalty does a similar job with money instead of a termination right.

Where is it common, and where is it rare?

Licence type Is a minimum likely? Why
Exclusive licence of a patent Very likely The owner cannot earn from anyone else
Sole licence Likely, often lower The owner keeps its own rights
Non-exclusive licence Less common Other licensees spread the risk
Know-how or process licence with a lump sum Rare The owner is paid upfront
Licence of a pending application Sometimes, with a delayed start The patent may not be granted

Indian institutional policies rarely publish a standard minimum. Expect it to be negotiated deal by deal, and to be linked to the exclusivity you ask for. Our post on sole and exclusive licences explains that link in detail.

A worked example over five years

The numbers here are invented to show the method.

A Pune MSME takes an exclusive licence for a coating technology. The royalty is 3% of net sales. The licensor asks for a minimum annual royalty of ₹5 lakh from year 1. The MSME forecasts slow early sales.

Year Net sales Royalty at 3% Minimum Shortfall paid Total paid
1 ₹40 lakh ₹1.2 lakh ₹5 lakh ₹3.8 lakh ₹5 lakh
2 ₹1 crore ₹3 lakh ₹5 lakh ₹2 lakh ₹5 lakh
3 ₹2 crore ₹6 lakh ₹5 lakh Nil ₹6 lakh
4 ₹3 crore ₹9 lakh ₹5 lakh Nil ₹9 lakh
5 ₹3.5 crore ₹10.5 lakh ₹5 lakh Nil ₹10.5 lakh
Total ₹9.9 crore ₹29.7 lakh ₹5.8 lakh ₹35.5 lakh

The minimum costs the MSME ₹5.8 lakh over five years, all of it in years 1 and 2, when cash is tightest. Now suppose it negotiates a two-year holiday, with the minimum starting in year 3. The shortfall falls to nil, because sales clear ₹5 lakh of royalty from year 3. The licensor gets the same ₹29.7 lakh in royalty, and the MSME keeps ₹5.8 lakh in the years it needs it most.

That is the main point of negotiating a minimum. The amount matters less than when it starts.

How to negotiate a minimum annual royalty

Five levers on a minimum royalty

1
HolidayNo minimum for the first one or two years
2
Step-upA small minimum that rises with expected sales
3
CreditShortfall counts against future royalty
4
ExitConvert to non-exclusive instead of paying
5
Carve-outsPause for regulatory delay or force majeure
  1. Ask for a holiday. Start the minimum after the expected launch date, or after a regulatory approval. A medical device that needs a licence from the regulator cannot sell before it gets one.
  2. Step it up. A minimum of ₹1 lakh in year 2, ₹3 lakh in year 3 and ₹5 lakh from year 4 matches most sales curves better than a flat figure.
  3. Get credit for shortfalls. Ask that any shortfall paid can be set off against royalty above the minimum in later years. Licensors often accept a credit carried forward for one or two years.
  4. Keep an exit. If you miss the minimum, the agreement should let you convert to a non-exclusive licence, or return the licence, instead of owing the shortfall indefinitely.
  5. Carve out delays you cannot control. Regulatory approvals, a patent office objection or force majeure should pause the minimum.

Be ready to offer something back. A licensor that gives a holiday will often ask for a higher royalty rate, a larger upfront fee or milestone payments. Our guide to the upfront license fee shows how those trade against each other.

What the clause should say

A clear minimum royalty clause states:

  • the amount for each licence year, in rupees, and whether GST is extra;
  • when the licence year starts, and when the minimum first applies;
  • how the shortfall is calculated and the date it is due;
  • whether shortfalls are credited against later royalty, and for how long;
  • what happens on a missed payment: conversion to non-exclusive, notice and cure period, or termination;
  • what happens in the year the licence ends: a pro-rata minimum, or none.

Put every term in the signed agreement. A licence of a patent is valid only if it is in writing, contains all its terms and is duly executed, under section 68 of the Patents Act, 1970.

Tax on the shortfall payment

A shortfall payment is paid for the right to use the technology, so it is normally treated as royalty along with the running royalty. For a resident licensor, TDS on royalty is 10% under section 393(1) of the Income-tax Act, 2025, Table serial 6(iii), once payments to that licensor in the year cross ₹50,000. Individual and HUF payers should check whether they fall within that table. GST at 18% applies to the licence as a supply of services. Our post on GST and TDS on royalty covers both, including foreign licensors.

One hedge: tax treatment can turn on how the agreement words the payment. Have your chartered accountant read the clause before you sign, not after the first shortfall invoice.

Common mistakes

  • Accepting a flat minimum from day one when the product cannot be sold for 18 months.
  • Forgetting GST on the shortfall invoice when budgeting.
  • No exit, so a failed product leaves you paying a minimum every year until the patent expires.
  • Confusing the minimum with the upfront fee. They are separate payments, and both can apply.

If you are still choosing a technology, compare options before you negotiate. Zernyx Hub has mapped patents from universities across India with AI business insight on each, which helps you judge whether a licensor's minimum matches the market for that technology. For the rate itself, read how much royalty is fair.

Common questions

What is a minimum annual royalty?

It is a floor written into a licence agreement. The licensee pays a running royalty on sales, but if that royalty for the year is below the agreed minimum, it tops up the difference. It protects the licensor against a licensee that takes a licence and then sells little or nothing.

Is a minimum annual royalty the same as an upfront fee?

No. An upfront fee is paid once, at signing, for access to the technology. A minimum annual royalty recurs every year of the licence and is usually set against the running royalty, so in a good year it costs the licensee nothing extra.

Is TDS deducted on a minimum royalty shortfall payment?

A shortfall payment is paid under the licence for the use of the technology, so it is normally treated as royalty. For a resident licensor, TDS on royalty is 10% under section 393(1) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 once payments in the year cross ₹50,000, where the payer is a person required to deduct under that table. Confirm the treatment of your agreement with your chartered accountant.

Can a licensee negotiate the minimum annual royalty?

Yes. The usual levers are a holiday of one or two years before the minimum starts, a minimum that steps up over time, credit for shortfall payments against later royalty, and a right to convert an exclusive licence to non-exclusive instead of paying the minimum.

Sahil Sheikh
About the author

Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP

Chief IP & Technology Officer, Zernyx Innovations

Connect on LinkedIn

Find a technology you can own.

Search patented technologies from Indian universities and labs, check their readiness and license the right one on Zernyx Hub.

Explore Zernyx Hub

Keep reading

Looking for something else?