JournalLicensing

Cross-licensing between Indian companies: when it makes sense and how to structure it

Cross licensing agreement guide for Indian companies: when swapping patent rights beats litigation, balancing payments, Section 140 limits and Form 16 filing.

By Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP 7 min read
Short answer

In a cross licensing agreement, two patent holders each license patents to the other. Section 68 of the Patents Act, 1970 requires it in writing, with all terms, duly executed. It should be registered on Form 16 under Section 69, though that is not a condition of validity. Section 140 voids exclusive grant-backs and no-challenge clauses.

Two Indian companies make competing pumps. Each holds a patent the other's latest model seems to use. Each could sue, and each would face a counterclaim, years of cost and an uncertain result. The alternative is a cross-licence: each company licenses the other under the patents in dispute, and both go back to selling.

Cross-licensing is common among large technology companies abroad, but it is just as useful for Indian mid-sized firms, MSMEs and startups that hold a handful of patents each. This post explains when it makes sense, how to structure it, what Indian law requires, and a worked example of a balancing payment.

What is a cross-licence?

A cross-licence is a single agreement, or a pair of linked agreements, in which each party grants the other a licence under some of its patents. The scope can be narrow, covering one patent each for one product, or broad, covering whole portfolios in a field.

Type What each side grants Typical use
Narrow, product-specific Licence under named patents, for named products Settling one dispute
Field cross-licence Licence under all patents in a defined field Two competitors in the same product category
Portfolio cross-licence Licence under all patents, present and sometimes future, in a field Firms with large overlapping portfolios
Cross-licence with balancing payment Mutual licences plus money to the side with the stronger portfolio Unequal portfolios
Technology exchange Licences plus know-how and technical help Combining complementary technologies

The first question is always why both sides need the other's permission. If only one side needs a licence, it is an ordinary licence negotiation; see our guide to patent licensing in India.

When does a cross-licence make sense?

Situation Why a cross-licence helps
Mutual blocking Each side's product reads on the other's patent; neither can sell freely
Threatened litigation Settling by cross-licence avoids the cost of suit and counterclaim
Complementary technologies One firm has the process, the other the product design
Joint development Each brings background patents to a project and needs rights in the other's
Freedom to operate gap A freedom to operate search finds a competitor's patent you cannot design around, and you hold one they need

A cross-licence is weaker when one side has nothing the other needs. Then the patent holder has little reason to accept patents in place of money.

Building a cross-licence

1
Map the overlapWhich patents each product uses
2
Value each sideSales affected, strength, remaining term
3
Set the scopePatents, products, field, territory
4
Balance the valueRoyalty-free or a balancing payment
5
Sign and registerSection 68 writing, Form 16 filing

How do you value each side?

Valuation decides whether money changes hands. Each side should estimate, for each patent the other needs, the sales it affects, the royalty rate a willing licensee might pay, the patent's strength, and its remaining term. Indian patents last 20 years from the filing date, so a patent with three years left is worth far less than one with fifteen.

Factor Questions to ask
Sales affected How much of the other side's revenue depends on the patent?
Strength Is the patent granted, renewed, and likely to survive a validity challenge?
Remaining term How many years of protection are left?
Design-around Could the other side avoid the patent at reasonable cost?
Essentiality Is the patent needed for the product, or one option among several?

A strong patent the other side cannot avoid is worth more than several weak patents it can design around. Count quality, not numbers. Royalty rates gives typical ranges you can use to estimate value.

What does Indian law require?

Several provisions of the Patents Act, 1970 and the Competition Act, 2002 apply directly.

Provision What it says What it means for a cross-licence
Section 68, Patents Act A licence is valid only if in writing, with all its terms, and duly executed Both grants must be in the signed document, not in emails or side letters
Section 69, Patents Act Licences are registered on application to the Controller; unregistered documents are generally not admitted as evidence of title File Form 16 for each Indian patent each side licenses
Section 140, Patents Act Makes void conditions that force buying other goods from the licensor, bar use of other processes or articles, require exclusive grant-backs, bar validity challenges, or impose coercive package licensing No no-challenge clause, and grant-backs on improvements should be non-exclusive
Section 3(5), Competition Act Preserves the right to impose reasonable conditions needed to protect IP rights Conditions beyond the patents, such as price fixing or market sharing, are outside the shelter

Section 140 matters more in cross-licences than in ordinary licences, because each side is tempted to demand the other's future improvements. An exclusive grant-back is void; a non-exclusive one is generally acceptable. Our post on improvements clauses covers the drafting.

Portfolio cross-licences between competitors deserve legal review under the Competition Act. A cross-licence that only settles mutual patent claims is ordinary. One that also sets prices, splits territories or limits output is a different and riskier agreement.

How should the agreement be structured?

Clause What to write
Licensed patents A schedule for each side, by patent number, plus any family members
Licensed products and field Exactly what each side may make and sell
Territory India only, or wider; check where each side holds patents
Exclusivity Usually non-exclusive both ways
Balancing payment Amount, timing, and whether lump sum or royalty
Future patents Whether patents filed later are included, and until when
Improvements Non-exclusive grant-backs only, to stay clear of Section 140
Term and termination Usually until the last licensed patent expires; what happens if one side breaches
Change of control What happens if either company is acquired
Release Release of past infringement claims, if the deal settles a dispute

Change of control is easy to forget. If your competitor's licence passes to a large acquirer, you may have given broad rights to a much stronger rival. Many cross-licences let the other side end the licence, or narrow it, on a change of control.

Royalty-free or with a balancing payment

Royalty-free
Portfolios of similar value
Simple to administer
No royalty reports
vs
Balancing payment
One side's patents worth more
Lump sum or running royalty
Needs reports and audit rights

Pay or receive the difference in value, and keep the accounting simple.

A worked example

Illustration with invented figures. Company A and Company B make industrial pumps. A's product uses one of B's patents; B's product uses two of A's.

Item A's patents used by B B's patent used by A
Annual sales affected ₹20 crore of B's sales ₹12 crore of A's sales
Assumed royalty a willing licensee might pay 3% 3%
Notional annual royalty ₹60 lakh ₹36 lakh
Remaining term 12 years 9 years

The notional royalties differ by ₹24 lakh a year in A's favour. The parties agree mutual non-exclusive licences in India for pumps, and B pays A a balancing royalty of 1.2% on its affected sales, about ₹24 lakh a year at current volume, until A's patents expire. The agreement also halves the royalty if either of A's patents is revoked or lapses, because B would then need a licence under only one of them.

On tax, the balancing royalty is subject to TDS, which falls under section 393 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 from 1 April 2026. Whether each side's grant is a separate supply for GST, and how it is valued when no money changes hands, needs advice for your facts; GST and TDS on licence fees covers the general rules.

Common mistakes

  • Counting patents instead of valuing them.
  • Including a no-challenge clause, which Section 140 makes void.
  • Forgetting to register each side's licence on Form 16.
  • No change of control clause.
  • Adding price or territory terms that turn a patent deal into a competition problem.

My view: for two Indian firms with overlapping products, a narrow cross-licence covering only the patents in dispute is usually better than a broad portfolio deal, because it settles the real problem and keeps future inventions free. The hedge is that valuing patents is uncertain, and two honest valuations can differ widely; agree a method before you argue about numbers.

If you are looking for technologies to license in, Zernyx Hub has mapped patents from universities across India, with AI business insight on each. For the rest of the licence, see technology license agreement clauses.

Common questions

When does a cross-licence make sense?

When each company's product reads on the other's patents, so neither can sell freely without the other's permission. A cross-licence settles that mutual blocking without litigation and lets both keep selling. It also helps when two firms want to combine complementary technologies.

Does a cross-licence involve money?

Often it does. If one side's portfolio is worth more to the other, the weaker side pays a balancing payment, either a lump sum or a running royalty. Where the portfolios are of similar value, the licences may be royalty-free.

Do I need to register a cross-licence with the Patent Office?

Registration under Section 69 is not a condition of validity, but an unregistered document is generally not admitted as evidence of title under Section 69(5) unless the Controller or a court directs otherwise. File Form 16 for each Indian patent covered.

Can a cross-licence be anti-competitive?

It can if it goes beyond the licensed patents, for example by fixing prices or dividing markets. Section 3(5) of the Competition Act, 2002 preserves reasonable conditions needed to protect patent rights, but not restrictions that go further.

Sahil Sheikh
About the author

Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP

Chief IP & Technology Officer, Zernyx Innovations

Connect on LinkedIn

Find a technology you can own.

Search patented technologies from Indian universities and labs, check their readiness and license the right one on Zernyx Hub.

Explore Zernyx Hub

Keep reading

Looking for something else?