JournalLicensing

Sole license vs exclusive license: the difference and when to choose each

Sole license vs exclusive license under Indian patent law: who can use the invention, who can sue infringers under section 109, and when each fits your deal.

By Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP 7 min read

Part of the guide Licensing technology from Indian institutions: the complete guide for companies

Short answer

An exclusive licence lets only the licensee use the invention, excluding even the patent owner, as section 2(1)(f) of the Patents Act, 1970 defines it. A sole licence promises no other licensee but lets the owner keep using the invention. Only an exclusive licensee has the statutory right under section 109 to sue infringers itself.

The difference between a sole licence and an exclusive licence is one party: the patent owner. Under a sole licence the owner can still use the invention itself. Under an exclusive licence it cannot. That single point changes your competition, your price, and whether you can take an infringer to court without waiting for the owner.

Term sheets often use the two words loosely, and a licence called "exclusive" can still let the owner keep manufacturing if the grant clause says so. The label in the heading does not decide what you have. The grant clause does.

What does Indian law say?

The Patents Act, 1970 defines only one of the two. Under section 2(1)(f), an exclusive licence is a licence from a patentee that confers on the licensee, or on the licensee and persons it authorises, "to the exclusion of all other persons (including the patentee)", any right in respect of the patented invention.

"Sole licence" is not defined in the Act. It is a commercial term, so its meaning comes from your agreement. In practice it means the owner promises not to grant any other licence in the agreed scope, but keeps its own right to work the invention.

Three sections follow from the definition:

Provision What it says Effect on a sole licensee
Section 109 An exclusive licensee has the like right as the patentee to sue for infringement after the licence date; the patentee is joined as plaintiff or added as defendant No statutory right; depends on the contract
Section 82 For Chapter XVI (working of patents, compulsory licences, revocation), "patentee" includes an exclusive licensee Not treated as patentee
Section 68 A licence is not valid unless in writing, in a document with all its terms, duly executed Same rule applies

Section 110 gives a separate right to a compulsory licensee under section 84: if the patentee does not act within two months of being asked, that licensee can sue in its own name. It does not extend to a voluntary sole licence.

Sole licence vs exclusive licence

Sole licence
No other licensee in the scope
Owner can still use the invention
No statutory right to sue
Usually cheaper
vs
Exclusive licence
Excludes everyone, owner included
Defined in section 2(1)(f)
Can sue infringers under section 109
Costs more, with obligations

If the owner competes with you, only exclusivity protects your market

Who can use the invention under each one?

Picture three parties: the owner, you, and everyone else.

Who can use the invention in the licensed scope Non-exclusive Sole Exclusive
You, the licensee Yes Yes Yes
The patent owner Yes Yes No, unless the agreement reserves a right
Other licensees Yes No No

The last cell in the exclusive column matters. Universities and public institutes routinely reserve a right to use the invention for teaching and research. NIT Karnataka's 2024 Innovation and Entrepreneurship Policy keeps that right for academic and research use. A reservation limited to non-commercial research leaves your commercial exclusivity intact. A reservation that lets the owner sell does not, and turns your "exclusive" licence into a sole one in all but name.

Who can sue an infringer?

This is the practical difference most companies miss until a copy turns up in the market.

An exclusive licensee can file the suit itself under section 109 and recover for its own losses. The court takes into account the losses the licensee has suffered or is likely to suffer, or the profits made by infringing its rights. The patentee must be joined, as a co-plaintiff or as a defendant, but you do not need the owner's enthusiasm to start.

A sole licensee has no such statutory right. If the owner will not act, you may be stuck watching a competitor sell a copy. So a sole licence needs an enforcement clause:

  1. The owner must act on infringement within a fixed period after your written notice, for example 60 days.
  2. If it does not, you may sue in the owner's name, and the owner will join as a party and sign the papers needed.
  3. Costs and recoveries are split in an agreed ratio.
  4. Neither side settles in a way that grants the infringer a licence in your scope without your consent.

Write this in before signing. After an infringement starts, the owner has little reason to agree.

When should you choose each one?

Choose by asking one question: will the owner use the invention in your market?

Your situation Better choice Why
Owner is a university, IIT, NIT or lab that does not manufacture Sole may be enough; exclusive costs little more The owner will not compete with you
Owner is a company selling a competing product Exclusive, in your field or territory A sole licence leaves your biggest rival in place
You will invest heavily in approvals, plant or brand Exclusive You need to stop copies, and section 109 lets you sue
You are testing a market before committing Sole or non-exclusive with an option to upgrade Lower cost now, protection later
The owner refuses full exclusivity Sole, plus a strong enforcement clause Gets you most of the commercial benefit

Institutional policy may decide for you. NIT Calicut's Technology Transfer Policy 2024 says an exclusive licence shall not be allowed, except as a special case for an MNC or a mass manufacturer; limited exclusivity for an initial five years may be considered if justified, at a higher fee. NIT Karnataka considers exclusivity only where the industry partner fully funded the R&D. Our guide to licensing from an NIT has the detail. Where full exclusivity is off the table, a sole licence in a defined field is often the realistic ask.

A worked example: what each one costs you

The figures here are invented to show the method.

A Hyderabad MSME licenses a sensor patent from a device company that already sells its own sensor in India. The company offers a sole licence at ₹12 lakh upfront plus 3% royalty, or an exclusive licence for India at ₹25 lakh upfront plus 4%.

The MSME forecasts ₹3 crore of annual sales with the exclusive licence. With the sole licence, it expects the owner to keep about a third of the market, so ₹2 crore.

Over 5 years Sole Exclusive
Sales ₹10 crore ₹15 crore
Upfront fee ₹12 lakh ₹25 lakh
Royalty ₹30 lakh (3%) ₹60 lakh (4%)
Total paid to licensor ₹42 lakh ₹85 lakh
Sales less licence payments ₹9.58 crore ₹14.15 crore

The exclusive licence costs twice as much but leaves ₹4.57 crore more in sales. Against a university owner that would never manufacture, the same sum would favour the sole licence, because the extra ₹1 crore a year of sales would not exist. The forecast of what the owner will do is the number that decides it, and it is also the one most worth testing in conversation before you sign. For how upfront fees and royalties trade against each other, see running royalty vs lump sum.

Drafting points for either licence

  • Define the scope: field of use, territory, term and the patents and applications covered.
  • Spell out what the owner keeps: research use only, or also commercial use.
  • Add the enforcement clause above, or confirm section 109 rights for an exclusive licence.
  • State whether you may sublicense. An exclusive licensee often needs to, for contract manufacturing.
  • Put every term in one signed document to meet section 68, then record it on Form 16 under section 69, as our guide to patent licensing in India explains.

An honest limit: because the Act does not define a sole licence, a court reading an unclear grant clause has only the contract's words to go on, and the outcome is hard to predict. Do not leave it unclear.

Before the licence comes the search. Zernyx Hub has mapped patents from universities across India, with AI business insight on each, so you can see who owns what before deciding how much exclusivity to ask for. For the broader exclusive versus non-exclusive question, read what a startup should ask for when licensing IP.

Common questions

What is the main difference between a sole and an exclusive licence?

Whether the patent owner can still use the invention. Under an exclusive licence, as section 2(1)(f) of the Patents Act, 1970 defines it, everyone else is excluded, including the patentee. Under a sole licence, the owner agrees not to license anyone else but keeps its own right to use the invention.

Can a sole licensee sue for patent infringement in India?

The Patents Act gives the right to sue in section 109 to the holder of an exclusive licence, with the patentee joined as a party. A sole licence is not an exclusive licence under section 2(1)(f), so a sole licensee should get a clause requiring the patentee to sue, or to let the licensee sue in the patentee's name.

Is a sole licence cheaper than an exclusive licence?

Usually, because the owner gives up less. How much cheaper depends on whether the owner will actually use the invention. A university that does not manufacture loses little by granting exclusivity, so the price gap is small; a company that sells competing products gives up a lot, so the gap is wide.

Do sole and exclusive licences need to be registered in India?

Both must be in writing with all their terms and duly executed to be valid under section 68. Registration under section 69 on Form 16 is not a condition of validity, but an unregistered licence cannot normally be used as evidence of title under section 69(5), so record it.

Sahil Sheikh
About the author

Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP

Chief IP & Technology Officer, Zernyx Innovations

Connect on LinkedIn

Find a technology you can own.

Search patented technologies from Indian universities and labs, check their readiness and license the right one on Zernyx Hub.

Explore Zernyx Hub

Keep reading

Looking for something else?