US vs Indian patent license clauses: what changes for the licensee
US patent license agreement vs an Indian one: how writing, recording, royalties after expiry, no-challenge, marking and working reports differ for licensees.
A US patent license agreement and an Indian one differ in six places that matter to a licensee: how the licence is made valid, recording, royalties after the patent expires, no-challenge clauses, patent marking and working reports. In India, section 68 of the Patents Act requires a written licence, and every licensee files Form 27 once every three financial years.
An Indian company licensing a US patent, or a US company licensing an Indian one, often signs a template written for the other country. Most clauses travel well. Grant, field, territory, royalty rate and reporting look much the same in both. A handful do not, and those are the ones that cause disputes years later.
This post sets out the six differences that matter most to a licensee, with the statute or case behind each, and a decision table you can use when you mark up the draft. It assumes you know the basic structure of a licence; if not, start with technology license agreement clauses.
Which clauses change between a US and an Indian patent licence?
| Clause or issue | United States | India | What the licensee should do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Validity and form | An assignment of a patent or application must be by an instrument in writing (35 U.S.C. 261) | A licence is valid only if in writing, with all terms in one document, duly executed (section 68) | Sign a complete written agreement in both systems; side letters are a risk in India |
| Recording | An assignment is void against a later buyer for value without notice unless recorded at the USPTO within three months or before that purchase (35 U.S.C. 261) | The licensee applies to the Controller to register its interest (section 69); an unregistered document is not admitted as evidence of title unless the Controller or court directs otherwise (section 69(5)) | Register an Indian exclusive licence; check whether your US deal needs recording |
| Royalty after expiry | No royalty for use after the patent expires (Kimble v. Marvel, 2015) | The licensee can end the contract on three months' notice once all protecting patents expire (section 141) | Split payments between patent rights and know-how in both |
| Restrictive conditions | Assessed mainly under antitrust law | Tie-ins, bars on using other products or processes, exclusive grant-backs and coercive package licensing are void (section 140) | Remove tie-ins, exclusive purchase and exclusive grant-back clauses from an Indian licence |
| No-challenge clause | Licensee estoppel is not the general rule (Lear v. Adkins, 1969) | A condition preventing challenges to validity is void (section 140) | Strike a no-challenge clause from an Indian licence; agree what happens to royalty if a challenge succeeds |
| Marking and working | Without marking, damages run only from actual notice (35 U.S.C. 287) | Patentee and licensee file Form 27 every three financial years (section 146) | Put marking duties on the licensee in the US and Form 27 cooperation in India |
Sources: 35 U.S.C. 261, 35 U.S.C. 287, Kimble v. Marvel, Lear v. Adkins, and sections 68, 69, 140 and 141 of the Patents Act, 1970.
How is a licence made valid and recorded?
In India, section 68 is strict. A licence, like an assignment or mortgage, is not valid unless it is in writing, the agreement is reduced to a document embodying all its terms and conditions, and the document is duly executed. A deal agreed by email with a term sheet attached, then "finalised later", is exposed.
Registration is a separate step. Under section 69(1), a licensee applies to the Controller to register its interest. Registration is not a condition of validity. What section 69(5) does is stop an unregistered document being admitted as evidence of title, unless the Controller or court records reasons for admitting it. For an exclusive licensee who may one day need to enforce or defend its position, that is reason enough to register.
The US statute speaks of assignments. Section 261 requires a written instrument, and an assignment not recorded at the USPTO within three months, or before a later purchase or mortgage, is void against a later buyer for value without notice. Whether and how a licence should be recorded is a question for US counsel, case by case.
Can royalties continue after the patent expires?
This is the clause most often copied wrongly from one system to the other.
In the US, the Supreme Court held in Kimble v. Marvel that "a patent holder cannot charge royalties for the use of his invention after its patent term has expired." The Court kept the 1964 Brulotte rule and pointed to lawful alternatives: deferred payment for use before expiry, royalties tied to non-patent rights, royalties that run until the last patent in a bundle expires, and arrangements such as joint ventures.
India reaches a similar place by a different road. Section 141 lets a licensee end a contract for a patented article or process, on three months' written notice, once every patent that protected it has ceased to be in force, whatever the contract says. A royalty that runs for ten years on a patent with four years left is therefore at risk in both countries.
The practical fix is the same. Separate what you pay for the patent from what you pay for know-how, data and support, and give each its own term.
Royalty after the patent ends
Price patent rights and know-how separately in both.
Which restrictive clauses fail in India?
Section 140 makes certain conditions in a licence to make, use or work a patented article or process unlawful and void. They include conditions that require the licensee to buy other articles from the licensor, that stop the licensee using articles or processes not supplied by the licensor, and conditions providing for exclusive grant-back, preventing challenges to the patent's validity, or coercive package licensing. Under section 140(2), putting such a condition in a separate agreement does not save it. Section 140(3) goes further: subject to a limited exception, it is a defence in infringement proceedings that such a contract was in force at the time.
A US template written for a licensor that also sells raw materials or equipment often has an exclusive purchase clause. In an Indian licence, strike it, or turn it into a quality specification the licensee can meet from any supplier. Check the improvements clause too: a duty to assign or exclusively license back every improvement is an exclusive grant-back.
What about no-challenge clauses?
In the US, Lear v. Adkins (1969) held that licensee estoppel is no longer the general rule; contract doctrine gives way to the public interest in testing patents. A clause that forbids the licensee from ever challenging validity is therefore weak there.
India deals with it in the statute. Section 140(1)(iii) lists a condition preventing challenges to the validity of the patent among the conditions that are void, so a US-style no-challenge clause should come out of an Indian licence. Some licensors try a softer clause instead, letting the licensor terminate if the licensee challenges. Whether a court would treat that as a prevention of challenge under section 140 has not, as far as I can find, been tested, so take advice before relying on it. Either way, agree in advance what happens to royalties already paid if a challenge succeeds.
What reporting does each country expect?
In India, IP India's Form 27 FAQ says every patentee and every licensee must file Form 27, once for each period of three financial years, within six months of the period's end. One form can cover several related patents granted to the same patentee. The licensor needs your data, so the licence should say who files and who supplies what.
In the US, the patent owner gives public notice by marking products with the patent number or a virtual marking web address. Without marking, damages are recoverable only after the infringer was notified. A licensee who sells unmarked products can therefore weaken the licensor's enforcement, which is why US licences usually make marking a licensee duty.
A worked example in rupees
Illustration with invented figures. A Pune MSME licenses a US patent for India, and a matching Indian patent, from a US company. The Indian patent has five years left. Know-how and process support come with it. The draft says 5% of net sales for ten years.
| Item | Draft | Revised |
|---|---|---|
| Patent royalty, years 1 to 5 | 5% | 3.5% |
| Know-how royalty, years 1 to 5 | Included | 1.5% |
| Royalty after the Indian patent expires, years 6 to 10 | 5% | 1.5% on know-how only |
| Net sales a year (assumed) | ₹4,00,00,000 | ₹4,00,00,000 |
| Payment in year 6 | ₹20,00,000 | ₹6,00,000 |
The revised split costs the same during the patent's life and stands up after it. The draft's year 6 payment would invite a section 141 notice, and the licensor could lose the whole royalty instead of keeping a smaller, defensible one.
The licensee also deducts TDS on royalty paid to a non-resident. From 1 April 2026 that sits in section 393 of the Income-tax Act, 2025; see GST and TDS on royalty for rates and treaty relief.
Marking up a cross-border licence
Common mistakes
- Signing a short licence and leaving key terms to emails. Section 68 wants one complete document.
- Running one royalty to a fixed date without checking when each patent expires.
- Keeping a US-style exclusive supply, grant-back or no-challenge clause in an Indian licence.
- Forgetting that the licensee, not only the patentee, files Form 27 in India.
- Assuming a US patent gives any protection in India. It does not; check the Indian family. Patent due diligence covers how.
My view: the royalty split between patent and know-how is the single clause worth the most negotiation time in a cross-border deal, because it decides what you pay for a decade. I would not rely on any template for the no-challenge and grant-back clauses, because section 140 voids them in India while US law treats them differently.
If you are still choosing between a US technology and an Indian alternative, Zernyx Hub has mapped patents from universities across India, with AI business insight on each.
Common questions
Does a patent licence have to be in writing in India?
Yes. Section 68 of the Patents Act, 1970 says a licence is not valid unless it is in writing, the agreement is reduced to a document setting out all its terms and conditions, and it is duly executed. Registration under section 69 is a separate step and is not a condition of validity.
Can a US licensor charge royalties after the patent expires?
Not for use of the patent after expiry. In Kimble v. Marvel (2015) the US Supreme Court kept the Brulotte rule. The Court noted that parties can defer payments for use before expiry, tie royalties to non-patent rights such as know-how, or run royalties until the last patent in a bundle expires.
Can an Indian licensee end the licence when the patent expires?
Yes. Section 141 of the Patents Act, 1970 lets a licensee end a contract for a patented article or process, on three months' written notice, once every patent protecting it has ceased to be in force, whatever the contract says.
Does a licensee have to file Form 27 in India?
Yes. IP India's Form 27 FAQ says every patentee and every licensee in India must file it, once for each period of three financial years, within six months of the end of that period.