GuideTechnology transfer

Patent filing decision matrix: which disclosures a TTO should file, hold or release

A patent filing decision matrix for university TTOs in India: score each disclosure, decide file, hold or release, and know the fees and deadlines behind it.

By Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP 7 min read
Short answer

A patent filing decision matrix scores each invention disclosure on patentability, commercial interest, readiness, detectability of infringement and cost, then sorts it into file, hold or release. In India an educational institution filing online pays ₹1,600 to file and ₹4,000 to request examination. A provisional application buys 12 months to decide on the complete specification.

Most Indian universities do not run out of ideas to patent. They run out of money to keep patents alive, and out of time to license them. A filing decision matrix forces the question earlier: before the institution commits to drafting fees, examination and years of renewals, is this disclosure worth it?

This guide gives an IPR cell or technology transfer office a matrix it can adopt, the three outcomes it should produce, and the official fees and deadlines that sit behind each choice.

Why does a TTO need a written matrix?

Three reasons. Filing decisions made case by case drift towards filing everything, because saying no to a senior professor is hard. Rankings and accreditation reward patent counts: the NIRF 2025 engineering framework gives up to 10 marks for granted patents and up to 5 for published patents within its research and professional practice score. And a written rule protects the committee when it declines to file.

The matrix does not replace judgement. It gives the committee the same questions every time, and a record of why each decision was made. Our post on setting up an IPR cell covers who should sit on that committee.

The matrix: five questions, scored

Score each disclosure from 0 to 2 on each question. The scoring below is a working template, not an official standard; adjust the weights to your institution's policy.

Question 0 1 2
Is it patentable? Falls in a Section 3 exclusion or clearly anticipated Novel, but inventive step uncertain Novel with a clear technical advance over the closest prior art
Is anyone likely to pay for it? No identifiable market or company A sector with plausible interest A named company has asked, or a funder needs it protected
How ready is it? Idea only, no data Lab data, TRL 3 or so Working prototype, TRL 4 or above
Could infringement be detected? Hidden inside a process Detectable with effort Visible in the product
Is the cost justified? Broad international filing needed to have value India filing has some value Strong value from an Indian filing alone

Patentability is the gate. In India, Section 3 rules out several categories that university research often touches: Section 3(d) excludes new forms of known substances without enhanced efficacy, Section 3(i) excludes methods of treatment and diagnostic methods, and Section 3(k) excludes mathematical or business methods and computer programmes per se. A disclosure scoring 0 here should not go further, whatever its other scores.

Detectability is the question committees most often skip. If a licensee could never find out whether a competitor uses your process, the patent is hard to enforce and hard to sell. Our post on patenting or keeping it secret explains the trade-off.

Three outcomes: file, hold or release

What the total score should trigger

File (7 to 10)
Provisional now, or complete if data is ready
Name an owner for licensing
Set the 12-month decision date
vs
Hold or release (0 to 6)
Hold: keep confidential, gather data, review on a date
Release: inventors may publish
Record the reason either way

A patentability score of 0 means release, whatever the total.

File means the institution commits money. File a provisional application if the data is incomplete, because Section 9 gives 12 months to file the complete specification, after which the application is treated as abandoned. Name the person responsible for finding a licensee in that year.

Hold means the invention stays confidential and is reviewed on a fixed date, usually after a defined experiment or a conversation with industry. Hold works only if nothing is published in the meantime. India's grace period under Section 31 is narrow: it covers display at a notified exhibition and a paper read before a learned society, with the application due within 12 months. It does not cover an ordinary journal article. See published before filing for what happens when a paper goes out first.

Release means the institution will not file. The inventors may publish. Some policies let inventors file at their own cost after a release; check yours. A release decision is also a decision to let the knowledge spread, which is often the right outcome for a public institution.

The fees and deadlines behind each decision

Official fees for an educational institution filing online, from the First Schedule to the Patents Rules:

Step Form Educational institution, startup, small entity, natural person Others
File the application Form 1 ₹1,600 ₹8,000
Early publication (optional) Form 9 ₹2,500 ₹12,500
Request examination Form 18 ₹4,000 ₹20,000
Expedited examination, if eligible Form 18A ₹8,000 ₹60,000
Renewal, years 3 to 6 Renewal fee ₹800 a year ₹4,000 a year

The lower fee needs Form 28 filed alongside under Rule 7. If the application is later assigned to a company that does not qualify, the new applicant pays the difference, which matters when you license by assignment. The same lower tier applies to startups and to small entities, meaning enterprises within the medium-enterprise limits of the MSMED Act, so a university's industry partner often qualifies too.

Deadlines that shape the decision:

Deadlines a filing decision commits you to

Month 0Provisional filedPriority date secured
12 monthsComplete specificationAlso last day for PCT or Paris filing
18 monthsPublicationEarlier with Form 9
31 monthsRequest examinationForm 18, for filings from 2024 rules on
Counted from the priority date. Applications filed before the 2024 rule change keep the old 48-month period for Form 18.

Two more rules affect timing. Under Section 39, a resident must not file abroad without a foreign filing permit unless the Indian application was filed at least six weeks earlier. And for international protection, the Paris Convention priority period is 12 months, with India's PCT national phase at 31 months from priority. Our post on PCT filing for universities covers when that spend is justified.

How to run the matrix in committee

A matrix only helps if it is used the same way each time. A simple routine works for most IPR cells.

  1. Fix a cut-off. Disclosures received by a set date each month go to that month's meeting, unless a publication date forces an urgent decision.
  2. Ask the inventor to present for ten minutes, then leave the room while the committee scores. Scoring in front of the inventor tends to push every number up.
  3. Score independently first, then discuss. Differences of two points or more on any question are worth talking through.
  4. Record the score, the outcome, the reason in one sentence, and a review date for every hold.
  5. Tell the inventor in writing within a set number of days, with what would change a hold or release decision.
  6. Declare conflicts. A committee member who is a co-inventor, or who works closely with the inventor, should not score that disclosure.

Over a year, the record shows patterns: which departments disclose most, which scores led to licences, and whether the committee's patentability calls held up in examination. That evidence is what lets the cell adjust its weights sensibly rather than by instinct.

A worked example in rupees

The figures below are an illustration of official fees only. Drafting and attorney fees vary widely and are not included.

A disclosure scores 8 and the committee decides to file in India only. Through year 6, official fees for an educational institution come to ₹1,600 (Form 1) + ₹4,000 (Form 18) + ₹3,200 (renewals for years 3 to 6) = ₹8,800, or ₹11,300 with early publication. If the same patent is later held by a company outside the lower tier, the equivalent fees are ₹8,000 + ₹20,000 + ₹16,000 = ₹44,000, or ₹56,500 with early publication.

The official fees are rarely what hurts. Professional drafting, replies to examination reports and foreign filings cost far more, which is why the cost question in the matrix asks whether an Indian filing alone has value. Our guide to what a patent costs in India gives the full picture.

Common mistakes

  • Filing to meet a ranking target. Published and granted counts help a score; unlicensed patents still cost renewals every year.
  • Skipping the hold option. A month of extra data often turns a weak provisional into a strong one.
  • Letting a hold drift. Without a review date, held disclosures are forgotten and then published by accident.
  • Forgetting funders. Some sponsored research agreements decide who files and who pays; read them before scoring.
  • Never revisiting. A filing decision should be reviewed again at 12 months and at examination; see the portfolio review guide.

Most Indian IPR cells should release more disclosures than they do, and spend the savings on licensing the patents they keep. That is a judgement call each institution makes for itself, and some will weigh rankings differently. Zernyx IPMS keeps each disclosure's score, decision, review date and deadlines in one record, so the committee's reasoning is still there when the person who made it has moved on.

Common questions

What criteria should a university use to decide whether to file a patent?

Five work well: patentability, including the Section 3 exclusions; commercial interest from an identified company or market; technology readiness; whether infringement could be detected; and the full cost of filing and keeping the patent. Funder obligations and publication plans decide the timing.

What does it cost a university to file a patent in India?

Official fees for an educational institution filing online are ₹1,600 for Form 1 and ₹4,000 for Form 18, with Form 28 filed alongside. Renewal fees for years 3 to 6 are ₹800 a year. Attorney fees for drafting are extra and vary widely.

What does it mean to hold a disclosure?

Hold means the TTO keeps the invention confidential and does not file yet, while the team collects missing data or tests industry interest, with a fixed date to decide again. It only works if nobody publishes in the meantime.

Can a university file first and decide later?

Partly. A provisional application under Section 9 secures the filing date, and the complete specification is due within 12 months or the application is treated as abandoned. That year is the time to find a licensee or strengthen the data.

Sahil Sheikh
About the author

Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP

Chief IP & Technology Officer, Zernyx Innovations

Connect on LinkedIn

Manage every patent in one place.

Zernyx IPMS is an IP management system to manage patents, filings and IP portfolios end to end.

Explore Zernyx IPMS

Keep reading

Looking for something else?