Licensing a patent application before grant: risks, fees and clauses
How to license a pending patent in India: what rights exist before grant, the risks if claims narrow or are refused, and the fee and clauses that protect you.
Part of the guide Licensing technology from Indian institutions: the complete guide for companies
A company in India can license a patent application before it is granted. From publication, section 11A(7) of the Patents Act, 1970 gives the applicant rights as if a patent had been granted, but no infringement suit can be filed until grant. Price for the risk that claims narrow or are refused, and step the fee up on grant.
You can license a patent application in India before the patent is granted, and many university and lab deals happen at exactly this stage. The technology is fresh, the institution wants it used, and you want to be first. The catch is that you are paying for a right that does not fully exist yet. The claims may be narrowed in examination, opposed by a competitor or refused. A good pending-patent licence prices that risk and says what happens in each case.
What rights exist before grant?
The key provision is section 11A(7) of the Patents Act, 1970. From the date an application is published, the applicant has "the like privileges and rights as if a patent for the invention had been granted" on that date. The same subsection says the applicant cannot start infringement proceedings until the patent is granted.
Publication normally happens 18 months after the filing or priority date, whichever is earlier, under rule 24, unless the applicant asks for early publication.
A pending patent's life, counted from first filing
Three things follow for a licensee:
| Stage | What the applicant can do | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Filed, not published | Nothing against third parties | You pay for know-how and a future right |
| Published, not granted | Has rights from publication; cannot sue until grant | Copying can be pursued after grant, back to publication |
| Granted | Can sue for infringement | Full value of the licence |
Examination does not start on its own. Someone must file Form 18, the request for examination: within 31 months from the priority or filing date for applications filed on or after 15 March 2024, and within 48 months for earlier ones. Check that it has been filed. An application with no Form 18 by the deadline is treated as withdrawn.
Is a licence of an application valid?
Section 68, which makes a licence of a patent valid only if it is in writing with all its terms and duly executed, refers to patents and interests in a patent. It does not mention applications. A licence of a pending application is still a binding contract under ordinary contract law. Write it to the section 68 standard anyway, with every term in one signed document, so it stays valid without amendment once the patent is granted.
An assignment of an application is different from a licence. Under section 20, a person entitled to the application under a written assignment can ask the Controller to let the application proceed in its name. That is how ownership changes before grant. A licence leaves ownership with the applicant.
What are the risks?
What can happen to a pending application
- Narrowed claims. Applications are often amended during examination. Your product may fall outside the claims that finally issue. Our guide to responding to an FER shows how this happens.
- Pre-grant opposition. Under section 25(1), any person can oppose a published application before grant. A competitor who knows you have licensed it has a reason to.
- Refusal or abandonment. The applicant may miss a deadline, stop paying or decide not to pursue it.
- Ownership gaps. If an inventor has not assigned rights to the institution, the institution may not be able to license all of them. Check the assignment chain as described in our patent due diligence checklist.
How should the fee be structured?
Split the payments so that you pay more as the risk falls. The figures below are invented to show the method.
A Chennai MSME licenses a published sensor application from an IIT on an exclusive basis for India.
| Payment | When | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Signing fee | At signature | ₹6 lakh |
| Grant milestone | Within 30 days of grant | ₹9 lakh |
| Royalty before grant | On net sales | 2% |
| Royalty after grant | On net sales, if your product is within the granted claims | 4% |
| If refused | Licence converts to a know-how licence | 1% royalty, no further fees |
If the patent is granted with claims that still cover the MSME's product, the institution receives ₹15 lakh in fees and the full 4% royalty from grant onwards, only later than an upfront deal. If the patent is refused, the MSME has paid ₹6 lakh and keeps using the know-how at a lower rate. That is a fair split of risk, and it is worth proposing even when the first term sheet asks for everything upfront.
For how upfront and running payments trade against each other, see our guide to the upfront license fee.
Clauses a pending-patent licence needs
- Definition of licensed patents. List the application number and include any patent granted on it, divisional applications and corresponding foreign filings you need.
- Prosecution. Who files Form 18, replies to the FER and defends any opposition, who pays, and your right to see the papers and comment before amendments are filed.
- Claim change clause. If the granted claims no longer cover your product, the royalty drops to the know-how rate, or you may terminate.
- Refusal clause. What happens if no patent is granted: conversion, refund of part of the signing fee, or termination.
- Abandonment. If the applicant decides to drop the application, it must tell you in time for you to take over prosecution at your cost, or take an assignment.
- Exclusivity start. Exclusivity runs from signing, not from grant.
- Recording. Record the licence with the Patent Office on Form 16 after grant. Validity comes from the signed agreement. Registration under section 69 matters for proof, because an unregistered licence is generally not admitted as evidence of your rights under section 69(5) unless the Controller or court directs otherwise.
Our post on patent licensing in India covers recording and Form 27 working statements after grant.
Due diligence on a pending application
A pending application needs more checking than a granted patent, because less has been tested. Before you sign:
- Read the published claims and the complete specification, and ask whether your product falls within the main claim.
- Check on IP India's public search that Form 18 has been filed, and whether a first examination report has issued. If it has, read the objections and the reply.
- Search for pre-grant oppositions filed against it.
- Confirm the applicant owns the application: inventor assignments, or the institution's IP policy, should show a clear chain.
- Ask for any search report from a corresponding foreign or PCT filing. An international search report is a quick, independent view of the prior art.
None of this needs to be expensive. A patent agent can usually review the file history of a single application in a few days, and the review often changes the fee you should offer.
Should you license now or wait?
| Your situation | Better choice |
|---|---|
| Competitors are circling and the institution licenses non-exclusively | License now, with milestone pricing |
| You need a year of testing before deciding | An option agreement to reserve the technology |
| Your product depends on one broad claim that faces strong prior art | Wait for the examination report |
| The application is unpublished and the inventor is still writing papers | License the know-how now and watch the filing |
Waiting has a cost too. A good university technology can be licensed to someone else while you wait, and a university may grant exclusivity to the first credible company. In most cases, licensing at publication, once you have read the claims and a search report, is the sensible point.
One honest limit: no fee structure removes the risk that examination takes years. Applications can stay pending well past the Form 18 deadline, so build your business plan on the product working, not on the grant date. If the applicant qualifies, expedited examination can shorten the wait, as our post on expedited examination explains.
Finding pending technologies worth a look
Many licensable university technologies are still applications. Zernyx Hub has mapped patents from universities across India with AI business insight on each, so you can shortlist pending inventions by commercial fit before you read the claims and contact the institution.
Common questions
Can you license a patent that has not been granted yet in India?
Yes. A licence of a pending application is a contract between the applicant and the company. Public institutions do it often: ICMR's 2024 collaboration guidelines provide for licensing technologies once IP has been filed, alongside other conditions such as validation. The agreement should say what happens if the patent is granted with narrower claims or refused.
What rights does a patent applicant have before grant?
Under section 11A(7) of the Patents Act, 1970, from the date of publication the applicant has like privileges and rights as if a patent had been granted on the date of publication. But it cannot start infringement proceedings until the patent is actually granted.
Should a licence fee be lower for a pending patent?
Usually, because the licensee carries the risk that no patent, or a narrower one, is granted. A common structure is a smaller upfront fee at signing, a milestone payment on grant, and a royalty that starts lower and rises once the patent issues.
Can a licence of a pending application be registered with the Patent Office?
Licences are recorded on the register of patents under section 69, which covers granted patents, so recording normally follows grant. An assignment of an application is handled differently: under section 20 the Controller can direct the application to proceed in the assignee's name.