Improvements clause: who owns what you build on a licensed technology
How an improvements clause in a license agreement decides who owns what you build on a licensed technology in India, and what Section 140 makes void.
Part of the guide Licensing technology from Indian institutions: the complete guide for companies
An improvements clause in a license agreement decides who owns changes either party makes to the licensed technology. In India, Section 140 of the Patents Act makes a condition providing for exclusive grant-back void. A licensee should own its own improvements, offer at most a non-exclusive licence back, and get the licensor's improvements included or on fixed terms.
Every licensee changes the technology it licenses. You scale the process, swap a raw material, redesign a part to suit your line, or find a better operating window. Within a year or two, the version you run is not quite the version you licensed. The improvements clause decides who owns that difference, and it is a clause that is easy to skim at signing.
This guide is for Indian companies and MSMEs taking a licence from a university, a public lab or another company. It covers the three questions the clause has to answer, what the Patents Act makes void, and a worked example of what a bad clause costs.
What does an improvements clause actually decide?
An improvement is any change that builds on the licensed technology: a new formulation, a better process step, a modified device, a new use. The clause should settle three separate things, and most draft clauses settle only one.
| Question | Licensee should ask for | Licensor often asks for |
|---|---|---|
| Who owns the licensee's improvements? | The licensee, outright | Ownership by the licensor, or joint ownership |
| What does the licensor get from them? | Nothing, or a non-exclusive licence back | An exclusive or free licence back |
| Do the licensor's later improvements come to you? | Yes, included in the licence at no extra fee | Only on new terms, if at all |
Read the third row twice. A licence covers what it defines and nothing more. IIT Mandi's IPR policy says this directly: the licence "may be restricted to the IP in question and not its enhancements or modifications." If the inventor's lab improves the process next year and your licence is silent, the better version may go to someone else.
What does Indian law say?
There is no default rule in the Patents Act on who owns licence improvements. The contract decides, which is why the clause matters. What the Act does is limit what a licensor may demand.
Section 140(1) says it is not lawful to insert, in a licence to manufacture or use a patented article or to work a patented process, a condition whose effect may be "to provide exclusive grant back, prevention to challenges to validity of Patent & Coercive package licensing", and that any such condition shall be void. Two more parts of the section matter here:
- Under Section 140(2), putting the condition in a separate agreement, before or after the licence, does not save it.
- Under Section 140(3), in an infringement suit, it is a defence to prove that a contract relating to the patent containing an unlawful condition was in force at the time. The defence does not apply if the patentee was not a party to that contract and proves the condition was inserted without its knowledge and consent. A licensor that insists on an exclusive grant-back can weaken its own patent enforcement.
So a clause that says "all improvements made by the Licensee shall be exclusively licensed to the Licensor" is void in a patent licence. A clause that gives the licensor a non-exclusive licence back is the usual compromise and does not run into this wording. Section 140 does not name an outright assignment of the licensee's improvements to the licensor. It has the same effect as an exclusive grant-back, and a court could well read it that way. Do not sign one, and a licensor should not rely on one.
Section 140 applies to patent licences. A pure know-how or trade secret licence is outside its words, though general contract law still applies. Our guide to know-how licences covers that case.
Two improvements clauses, two different outcomes
Own your improvement and offer, at most, a non-exclusive licence back.
How should the clause be drafted?
A licensee-friendly clause has seven parts. Each is short.
1. A definition that works both ways. Define "Improvement" as a change to the licensed technology that would, if used without the licence, infringe the licensed patents or use the licensed know-how. A narrower definition keeps your separate, independent developments out of the clause altogether.
2. Licensee improvements belong to the licensee. Say so in one sentence. Add that the licensee may file patent applications on them in its own name.
3. At most a non-exclusive licence back. If the licensor needs one, limit it: non-exclusive, for the licensor's own research and, if you agree, for its other licensees outside your field and territory. Decide whether it is free or carries a royalty to you. Universities often ask for research use only. IIT Kanpur's IPR policy, for example, keeps a non-exclusive, free, irrevocable licence to use all IP produced at IITK for teaching and research.
4. Licensor improvements come to you. Ask that any improvement the licensor makes during the term falls within your licence at no extra upfront fee, or at least that you get a first right to license it on terms fixed in the agreement, such as the same royalty rate.
5. Disclosure, with a time limit. Each side tells the other about relevant improvements within a set period, say 60 days, under the confidentiality clause. Disclosure is not a transfer of ownership; say that too.
6. Joint improvements. If both teams contribute, the improvement is jointly owned. Then set the rules the law will not set for you: who files, who pays, who may license, and how income is shared. Our guide to joint patents between universities and industry covers the traps.
7. What happens at the end. State that your improvements stay yours after the licence ends, and whether the licensor's licence back survives. If your improvement cannot be used without the base patent, it has little value after termination unless you can keep a licence to the base technology. A survival right, or a buy-out price for the base licence, is worth asking for.
Exclusivity changes the bargaining. An exclusive licensee usually gets licensor improvements included because it is the only route to market. A non-exclusive licensee should expect to pay for them. See exclusive or non-exclusive.
From an improvement to a clear record
A worked example: what a bad clause costs
The figures below are an illustration with invented numbers. An MSME licenses a coating process from a public lab: ₹10 lakh upfront and 3% royalty on net sales. In year two its engineers cut curing time by a third and file a patent on the change. Sales of the improved product reach ₹2 crore a year. A second company asks the MSME for a licence to the improvement for ₹8 lakh upfront plus 2% royalty.
| Clause in the licence | Who owns the improvement | What the MSME earns from the second company (year one) |
|---|---|---|
| Licensee owns; non-exclusive licence back to licensor for research | The MSME | ₹8 lakh upfront, plus 2% of the second company's sales |
| Licensee owns; licensor gets a non-exclusive licence back it may pass to its other licensees | The MSME | Probably little: the second company can get it from the licensor |
| Exclusive grant-back or assignment to licensor | Disputed; the condition is void in a patent licence but the fight costs time | Nothing until the dispute is settled |
The middle row is the one to notice. It looks harmless, yet if the licensor may pass your improvement to its other licensees, your best customers for it will go to the licensor instead. Limit any licence back to the licensor's own research, or charge for the wider right.
The royalty side matters too. If your improvement is a separate patent, make sure the royalty base for the original licence does not quietly grow to cover the improved product's added value. The 3% should apply to what the licensed technology contributes. Our guide to royalty rates covers how royalty bases are set.
The paperwork: Sections 68 and 69
The licence, and any later licence back of an improvement, is valid when it is in writing, contains all its terms and is duly executed, under Section 68. Registration with the Patent Office under Section 69, on Form 16 (₹1,600 per patent for the lower fee tier, which covers natural persons, startups, small entities and educational institutions), is not a condition of validity. An unregistered document is, under Section 69(5), not admitted as evidence of title unless the Controller or a court directs otherwise. Recording the licence back makes the ownership position clear to the next investor or buyer who looks.
If the improvement is patented abroad, check the law there too. Rules on grant-backs differ between countries, and a clause that is acceptable in one may be void in another.
Common mistakes
- Leaving the clause out. Silence does not mean you own your work; it means you will argue about it later.
- Defining "Improvement" too widely. "Anything related to the field" can capture products that never used the licensed technology.
- Disclosing before filing. Tell the licensor after your own patent application is in, or under a confidentiality clause that is clearly in force.
- Forgetting the licensor's improvements. Ask for them at signing, when you have the most bargaining power.
- Ignoring termination. An improvement that depends on the base patent is worth little once the licence ends.
For the rest of the agreement, see the clauses a technology licence agreement must get right and, if you plan to bring in partners, the sublicensing clause.
One honest caveat: Indian courts have said little about improvement clauses in technology licences specifically, so how a court would treat an outright assignment of improvements is not settled. Draft to avoid the question.
If you are still choosing which technology to license, Zernyx Hub has mapped patents from universities across India, with AI business insight on each, so you can compare options before the clause negotiation starts. Start at Zernyx Hub.
Common questions
Who owns an improvement a licensee makes to a licensed technology in India?
Whoever the agreement says. Indian law sets no default rule for licence improvements, so the contract decides. If the agreement is silent, ownership follows general principles of who made the invention, which invites disputes. Write the rule into the improvements clause.
Is a grant-back clause legal in India?
A non-exclusive grant-back is generally acceptable. Section 140(1) of the Patents Act makes void a condition in a patent licence whose effect is to provide exclusive grant-back, prevent challenges to the patent's validity or impose coercive package licensing. Under Section 140(3), such a condition in force can also give an alleged infringer a defence, subject to a proviso.
Does a licence automatically include the licensor's later improvements?
No. A licence covers what it defines. Some institutional policies say so plainly: IIT Mandi's IPR policy states that a licence may be restricted to the IP in question and not its enhancements or modifications. Ask for improvements to be included, or for a first right to license them on fixed terms.
Should a licensee patent its improvement separately?
Usually yes, if it is new and inventive. A separate patent gives you an asset you own outright, which you can license or use as a bargaining chip. File before you show it to the licensor, and register any licence back under Section 69 so the record is clear.