How to apply for a compulsory license in India: Section 84, Form 17 and what it costs
How to apply for a compulsory license in India under Section 84: the three-year rule, the grounds, Form 17 fees, the voluntary license request and timelines.
Any interested person can apply to the Controller for a compulsory licence once three years have passed from the grant of an Indian patent, on one of three grounds: the reasonable requirements of the public are not met, the invention is not available at a reasonably affordable price, or it is not worked in India. You apply on Form 17, which costs ₹2,400 online for a startup, small entity or individual and ₹12,000 for other companies. You must usually show you first tried to get a voluntary licence on reasonable terms, for a period that ordinarily does not exceed six months.
Your company needs a patented technology. You have written to the patent owner, offered fair terms and been refused, or simply ignored. Meanwhile the product is scarce or priced far beyond what Indian buyers can pay. Indian patent law gives you one more option: ask the Controller of Patents to grant a licence without the owner's consent.
That is a compulsory licence. It is rarely granted and should never be your first plan, but every R&D head and business development team should know how it works. This guide covers when you can apply, the grounds, the form and fees, the process and how to prepare. It is general information, not legal advice. Talk to a registered patent agent or patent lawyer before you file.
The short answer
Under Section 84 of the Patents Act, 1970, any interested person can apply for a compulsory licence once three years have passed from the grant of the patent. You apply on Form 17. The online fee is ₹2,400 for a natural person, startup, small entity or educational institution and ₹12,000 for others. You must show at least one of three grounds, and usually that you first tried to get a voluntary licence on reasonable terms, for a period that ordinarily does not exceed six months. If the Controller grants a licence, it is non-exclusive, non-assignable and comes with a royalty the Controller fixes.
The three grounds
Section 84(1) allows an application on any one of these grounds:
- The reasonable requirements of the public with respect to the patented invention have not been satisfied.
- The invention is not available to the public at a reasonably affordable price.
- The patented invention is not worked in the territory of India.
Section 84(7) explains when the public's reasonable requirements are treated as not met. Examples include:
- The patentee refuses to license on reasonable terms, and this harms an existing trade or industry in India, or leaves demand for the patented article not met adequately or on reasonable terms.
- The patentee's licence conditions hurt the making, use or sale of unpatented materials, or Indian trade or industry.
- The patentee forces exclusive grant-backs, bars licensees from challenging validity, or imposes coercive package licensing.
- The invention is not worked in India on a commercial scale to an adequate extent.
- Imports by the patentee, or by people it does not sue, prevent or hinder working in India.
The working ground is why Form 27 matters. Every patentee files a working statement with the Patent Office, and those statements are often the starting evidence in a compulsory licence case. Our post on Form 27 working statements explains what they contain and when they are due.
What the Controller weighs
Showing a ground is not enough. Under Section 84(6), the Controller considers:
- The nature of the invention, the time since the patent was sealed, and the steps the patentee or licensees have taken to use it fully.
- Your ability to work the invention to the public's advantage.
- Your capacity to take the financial risk of providing capital and working the invention.
- Whether you tried to get a licence on reasonable terms and failed within a reasonable period. The Explanation to the section says this period is ordinarily not more than six months.
The voluntary licence attempt does not apply in a national emergency, extreme urgency, public non-commercial use, or where the patentee's anti-competitive practices are established. Matters that arise after you file are not taken into account, so your case has to be complete on the day you apply.
Compulsory licence under Section 84: the path
The process, step by step
1. Check the timing. Count three years from the date of grant, not filing. Look up the grant date on IP India's public patent search.
2. Make a real voluntary licence request. Write to the patentee with specific, reasonable terms: field, territory, volume, royalty and price. Keep every letter and reply. If the patentee asks for more information, give it. A vague email will not carry your case.
3. File Form 17. Rule 96 of the Patents Rules says the application is made on Form 17. It should state your interest, the patent details, the facts behind your grounds, your attempts to get a licence, your ability to work the invention and the terms you propose. Attach your evidence.
4. Prima facie review. Under Section 87, the Controller first checks whether your application makes out a case for an order. If it does, you must serve copies on the patentee and anyone else with a recorded interest, and the Controller publishes the application in the Official Journal.
5. Opposition. The patentee or another interested person can oppose within the prescribed period, which the Controller may extend. The notice of opposition is filed on Form 14, which carries the same fee as Form 17. The Controller then hears both sides.
6. Possible adjournment. If the ground is non-working and the Controller thinks too little time has passed for the invention to be worked commercially, Section 86 allows an adjournment of up to 12 months in total, provided the patentee has promptly taken adequate steps to start working it in India.
7. Decision and terms. If the Controller grants the licence, Section 90 guides the terms: a reasonable royalty that considers the nature of the invention and the patentee's costs of developing, patenting and maintaining it; a non-exclusive and non-assignable licence; and supply mainly for the Indian market. Export is allowed where needed under Section 84(7)(a)(iii).
There is no fixed statutory deadline for the final decision. Plan for a contested process that may continue through appeal.
What it costs
From the First Schedule to the Patents Rules, for online filing:
| Item | Natural person, startup, small entity, educational institution | Others |
|---|---|---|
| Form 17: compulsory licence application | ₹2,400 | ₹12,000 |
| Form 14: notice of opposition (for the patentee or others) | ₹2,400 | ₹12,000 |
The official fee is the small part. The real cost is the evidence: market data on demand and supply, pricing analysis, technical proof that you can make the product, and legal fees for a contested hearing and any appeal. Check the current fee schedule on the IP India website before you file.
The case everyone cites
India's first compulsory licence went to Natco Pharma in March 2012, for Bayer's kidney and liver cancer drug sorafenib tosylate (Nexavar). Natco had asked Bayer for a voluntary licence in December 2010 and been refused. Natco proposed a price of about ₹8,800 for a month of therapy, against Bayer's price of about ₹2.8 lakh. The Controller fixed a royalty of 6%. In March 2013 the Intellectual Property Appellate Board upheld the licence and raised the royalty to 7%, and the Bombay High Court upheld it in 2014.
Two lessons from that case are useful for any applicant. First, the voluntary licence request was clear and documented. Second, the evidence on the public's requirements was specific: the court looked at how many patients needed the drug against how many the patentee actually supplied.
Natco v Bayer: India's first compulsory licence
Other routes in the Act
- Section 92: if the Central Government notifies a national emergency, extreme urgency or public non-commercial use, the Controller grants licences to interested applicants on terms it thinks fit. In some urgent public health cases, the usual Section 87 procedure need not be followed.
- Section 92A: a compulsory licence to make and export patented pharmaceutical products to a country with insufficient manufacturing capacity, where that country allows the import.
- Section 85: two years after the first compulsory licence, the Central Government or any interested person can apply to revoke the patent if it is still not worked in India, the public's reasonable requirements are still not met, or it is still not available at a reasonably affordable price.
Is this the right route for you?
For most companies, no, at least not first. A compulsory licence is slow, public and contested, and it gives you a non-exclusive right at a royalty you do not set. It makes sense when the patentee will not deal, the market need is large and documented, and you can actually manufacture and supply.
Before you go down this path, check two things. Is the patent still in force and valid in India? Our guide to freedom to operate searches explains how to check status, scope and expiry. And is there another technology that solves the same problem, which you could license on normal commercial terms? A voluntary licence, even at a higher royalty, is usually faster. Our post on fair royalty rates shows what moves those numbers.
Common mistakes
- Counting from filing instead of grant. The three years run from the grant date.
- A token licence request. Make a specific offer, wait a reasonable period and keep the record.
- Weak evidence of public need. Use numbers: demand, supply, price and the patentee's working data.
- No proof you can deliver. Show facilities, capital and a production plan.
- Expecting exclusivity. A compulsory licence is non-exclusive and cannot be assigned.
Looking for alternatives first
Often the quicker answer is a different technology that does the same job. Zernyx Hub, India's technology licensing marketplace for businesses, has mapped patents from universities across India, with AI-generated business insight on each, including commercial applications. You can search Zernyx Hub for licensable alternatives from universities, labs and inventors before you spend a year in a contested hearing.
FAQ
Who can apply for a compulsory licence in India?
Any interested person, under Section 84(1), including an existing licensee of the patent. In practice, the applicant must show it can work the invention and take the financial risk of doing so.
How long does the voluntary licence attempt have to last?
The Act asks whether you tried for a reasonable period. The Explanation to Section 84(6) says this ordinarily does not exceed six months.
Can the patentee oppose a compulsory licence application?
Yes. After the application is published, the patentee or any interested person can file a notice of opposition on Form 14 within the prescribed period, and the Controller hears both sides.
Who decides the royalty?
The Controller. Section 90 asks for a reasonable royalty that takes into account the nature of the invention and what the patentee spent developing, patenting and maintaining it.