TRL for BIRAC PACE: what academic and startup applicants must show
BIRAC PACE explained by TRL: what AIR and CRS applicants must show, minimum TRL 3 for CRS, funding limits, the industry partner and evidence reviewers check.
Part of the guide TRL levels explained: what TRL 1 to 9 really mean, and how to place your technology
BIRAC PACE has two parts. AIR funds academic proof-of-concept work for up to 24 months and ₹50 lakh, and needs proof of principle with preliminary data. CRS funds validation by an industry partner and needs evidence of proof of concept at minimum TRL 3, with validation-ready data. Both are under BIRAC's PACE guidelines of 16 April 2025.
PACE is the BIRAC scheme for academic labs with a result that might become a product. It funds the work that turns a promising bench finding into something a company would test, and then the company's validation of it. A common reason a PACE proposal struggles is a mismatch between the scheme chosen and the evidence the lab actually holds.
This guide reads PACE through technology readiness levels. Everything about the scheme below is from BIRAC's PACE scheme guidelines of 16 April 2025. Check the current call before applying, because BIRAC issues an RFP with each one.
What are the two parts of PACE?
PACE, Promoting Academic Research Conversion to Enterprise, has two components with different purposes and different evidence bars.
| AIR (Academic Innovation Research) | CRS (Contract Research Scheme) | |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Proof-of-concept development of a process or product by academia | Validation of an academic process or prototype by an industry partner |
| Industry partner | Optional | Mandatory |
| Entry evidence | Proof of principle and preliminary data (compulsory) | Proof of concept, minimum TRL 3, and validation-ready data (compulsory) |
| Duration | Up to 24 months; the Technical Expert Committee may extend | No time limit |
| Funding cap | Total project cost up to ₹50 lakh; non-recurring cost up to 10% | No ceiling; no non-recurring cost for the company partner |
| Not supported | Basic or exploratory research | |
| IP | With academia, or shared with industry as agreed | With academia; industry partner has first right of refusal |
Read the evidence row carefully. The only explicit TRL in the guidelines is the CRS minimum, TRL 3. AIR's bar is proof of principle, which on BIRAC's own scale comes before proof of concept.
Where does each component sit on the TRL scale?
BIRAC published sector-specific TRL definitions in 2018. The early stages, as its documents name them, run from ideation (TRL 1) and proof of principle (TRL 2) through proof of concept demonstrated (TRL 3) and established (TRL 4) to early-stage validation (TRL 5). Our post on the BIRAC BIG grant shows the same scale.
BIRAC's early TRL stages and the two PACE components
AIR takes a lab from proof of principle toward a prototype. The guidelines say the final milestone should be near industry readiness and the proposal must explain how the project will become "CRS ready". CRS starts from at least TRL 3 and covers prototype creation, small batches and comparative evaluation, up to large-scale validation toward commercial batch size. In TRL terms that is roughly TRL 3 to 5 and beyond, depending on the project. The guidelines do not set an exit TRL for either, so treat that mapping as a reading, not a rule.
What evidence should an AIR proposal carry?
On the bench, "proof of principle" means you have shown the mechanism works at all: the molecule binds, the sensor responds, the enzyme converts the substrate. You have not yet shown it works in the form a product would take.
For an AIR proposal, assemble:
- The preliminary data itself: raw readings, replicate counts, controls, and the conditions used. Reviewers read the figure legends.
- A clear statement of what is not yet shown. A proposal that admits the gap and plans to close it reads better than one that hides it.
- The PI's eligibility documents. The guidelines ask for at least one extramural project in the same area totalling three years, and at least one first- or lead-author paper in a Scopus or Web of Science indexed journal, or a filed patent.
- A product development path with a likely industry partner, explaining how the project becomes CRS ready.
- An undertaking that the same work is not funded by another agency.
What evidence should a CRS proposal carry?
CRS is where the TRL 3 minimum bites, and where missing evidence can disqualify the proposal outright. "Validation ready" means a partner could repeat your result. That needs more than a good figure.
| Evidence for CRS | What it looks like at the bench |
|---|---|
| Proof of concept, minimum TRL 3 | The function demonstrated in the intended format, with controls |
| Reproducibility | Repeated runs, ideally by a second person or on a second batch |
| Defined protocol | A written method the partner can follow, with critical parameters |
| Material characterisation | Purity, stability or calibration data, as the product needs |
| Validation plan | What the partner will test, at what scale, against what acceptance criteria |
| Partner's commitment letter | First right to monetise the technology, as the guidelines require |
| Background IP | Owned by the applicant; in-licensed technology from an incubator is not allowed |
The partner matters as much as the data. The guidelines list incorporation under the Companies Act, 2013, or at least 51% of shares held by Indian citizens holding Indian passports. The partner must also have adequate in-house facilities or be incubated at a recognised facility. If CRS follows an AIR project, BIRAC expects the same partner unless the change is justified.
For a general method of packaging readiness evidence, see how to prove your TRL. If you are short of TRL 3, moving from TRL 3 to TRL 4 covers the experiments that usually close the gap, and TRL 4 meaning shows what established proof of concept looks like.
How is a PACE proposal funded and reviewed?
Funding depends on who the institution is. Centre and state-owned institutions can receive up to 100% grant-in-aid. A private institution that has never had BIRAC grant-in-aid can get a one-time grant of up to ₹50 lakh; above that, BIRAC pays up to 70% of the excess. Startups under 10 years old at the close of the call, with no previous BIRAC grant, follow the same structure. Others, and companies over 10 years old, get at most 70% and contribute at least 30%.
Here is a worked example with invented numbers. A private university with no previous BIRAC grant and a ₹90 lakh CRS budget would receive ₹50 lakh plus 70% of the remaining ₹40 lakh, which is ₹28 lakh, for a total of ₹78 lakh. It would contribute ₹12 lakh itself.
How a PACE CRS proposal is reviewed
Applications go online only, through the BIRAC portal, during an active call. BIRAC runs two regular calls a year and may add need-based calls. AIR proposals go through eligibility screening, Area Review Panel shortlisting, a PI presentation and expert review if needed, with the final decision by the Technical Expert Committee. CRS adds a site visit or online due diligence and financial due diligence, and the Apex Committee, chaired by the Secretary, DBT, decides. Decisions are final, and requests for reconsideration are not entertained.
Common mistakes
- Applying to CRS with AIR-level evidence. A single positive experiment is proof of principle, not proof of concept.
- Calling data "validation ready" when only the PI's student can run the assay.
- Bringing an industry letter that commits to nothing. The guidelines ask for a commitment to exercise the first right to monetise.
- Using in-licensed background technology. The applicant must own the background IP.
- Proposing basic research under AIR. The scheme excludes it.
If your evidence is borderline, apply to AIR. A stretched TRL claim makes a reviewer doubt the rest of the proposal, and AIR is built to get you to CRS. Committees do read evidence differently, though, and a committed partner with its own validation capacity can change how a borderline CRS case is seen.
Before you write, it helps to check your level independently. In TRL Pro you answer questions about your technology and its evidence, and you get back a readiness level from TRL 1 to 9, assessed with Zernyx's own copyrighted framework (ZTRAF) covering more than 60 technology domains and subdomains. Try TRL Pro.
Common questions
What TRL does BIRAC PACE require?
PACE's guidelines of 16 April 2025 state a TRL only for CRS: evidence of proof of concept, minimum TRL 3, with validation-ready data, is compulsory and its absence can disqualify the proposal. For AIR, the guidelines ask for established proof of principle with preliminary data, which sits below proof of concept on BIRAC's scale.
How much funding does BIRAC PACE give?
AIR projects run up to 24 months with total cost capped at ₹50 lakh, and non-recurring cost no more than 10% of the total. CRS has no time limit and no ceiling. Government institutions can receive up to 100% grant-in-aid; private institutions and companies have caps and co-funding rules set out in the guidelines.
Does a startup apply for PACE directly?
The applicant is an academic institute, university, research foundation or national laboratory, with a permanent faculty or staff member as principal investigator. The funding rules also mention startups as primary applicant or collaborator, so check the current call. For CRS, an industry partner is mandatory; the guidelines list incorporation under the Companies Act, 2013, or at least 51% of shares held by Indian citizens holding Indian passports.
Who owns the IP from a PACE CRS project?
Under the 2025 guidelines, IP from a CRS project resides with the academic partner, and the industry partner has the first right of refusal to commercialise the new IP. Under AIR, IP may stay with academia alone or be shared with industry as the partners agree.