GuideTechnology readiness

TRL for chemical processes and new materials: what each level looks like, from flask to plant

TRL for chemical processes and materials: what TRL 1 to 9 look like from lab synthesis to miniplant, pilot and plant, and the evidence each level needs.

By Dr. Abhay Tharmatt, Research Scientist, R&D, Zernyx Innovations 8 min read

Part of the guide TRL levels explained: what TRL 1 to 9 really mean, and how to place your technology

Short answer

For a chemical process or a new material, TRL 1 to 3 cover the idea and a lab proof that the chemistry works. TRL 4 and 5 are process development at lab and miniplant scale, with the steps validated and then run under realistic conditions. TRL 6 is a pilot plant in a relevant environment, TRL 7 a demonstration and full-scale engineering, TRL 8 commissioning of the first plant, and TRL 9 routine production.

The standard TRL scale was written for hardware: components, prototypes, systems. A chemist or materials scientist reading it often struggles. What is a "prototype" when your technology is a catalyst, a solvent-free route to an intermediate, or a new polymer grade? Where does a 10-litre reactor sit? Is a pilot plant TRL 6 or 7?

This guide translates the nine levels into the language of chemical process development, from the first reaction in a flask to a plant in routine production. It is written for researchers and startups in chemicals, materials, catalysis, polymers and process engineering who need to place their technology honestly for a grant, an investor or a licensee.

The short answer

For a chemical process or new material, the levels follow the scale and integration of the process:

  • TRL 1 to 3: the idea, the concept and a lab proof that the chemistry works.
  • TRL 4 to 5: process development, first with the key steps validated in the lab, then run under realistic conditions, often in a miniplant.
  • TRL 6: a pilot plant in a relevant environment.
  • TRL 7: demonstration and full-scale engineering.
  • TRL 8: the first commercial plant commissioned and qualified.
  • TRL 9: routine production, proven over the full range of conditions.

The rule that matters most: move to the next level only after the current one is clearly achieved.

Two scales worth knowing

India's NTRAF. The National Technology Readiness Assessment Framework, published by the Office of the Principal Scientific Adviser, gives generic definitions for TRL 1 to 9. TRL 4 is component or system validation in the lab. TRL 5 is laboratory-scale validation of a similar system in a relevant environment. TRL 6 is an engineering or pilot-scale prototype demonstrated in a relevant environment. TRL 7 is a full-scale system prototype in an operational environment. NTRAF has no separate annex for chemicals or materials, but its manufacturing criteria apply directly to process work. For example, at TRL 4 key manufacturing processes are identified and assessed in the lab, at TRL 6 critical manufacturing processes are prototyped, and at TRL 8 manufacturing processes show acceptable yield and producibility.

A chemical-industry interpretation. A 2019 paper in Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research by Buchner and colleagues proposed TRL names specific to the chemical industry: idea, concept, proof of concept, preliminary process development, detailed process development, pilot trials, demonstration and full-scale engineering, commissioning, and production. These names are a useful way to read the generic scale for process work.

Use NTRAF when you report to an Indian funder, and name the scale in every proposal. Our post on TRL levels explained covers NTRAF in more detail.

The nine levels for a chemical process

TRL for a chemical process, in short

TRL 9Routine production over full conditions
TRL 8First plant commissioned and qualified
TRL 7Demonstration, full-scale engineering
Where most stall
TRL 6Pilot plant in a relevant environment
TRL 5Process run under realistic conditions
TRL 4Key process steps validated in the lab
TRL 3Proof of concept in the lab
TRL 2Concept: route and use case worked out
TRL 1Idea: a reaction or material is proposed

TRL 1, idea. A new reaction, catalyst or material is proposed, based on literature or a first observation. There is no process yet.

TRL 2, concept. You have worked out a route on paper: reagents, likely conditions, the product's target properties and the application. A first look at raw material availability and cost belongs here.

TRL 3, proof of concept. The reaction gives the target product reproducibly at lab scale, and you have characterisation data to prove what you made. For a material, you have measured the key property that makes it useful.

TRL 4, preliminary process development. The key steps, such as reaction, work-up, separation and purification, are validated together in the lab. You know yields, purity, main by-products and the parameters that matter, such as temperature, pressure, residence time and catalyst loading. A first mass balance and a rough cost estimate exist.

TRL 5, detailed process development. The process runs under conditions close to the real ones: technical-grade raw materials instead of reagent-grade, realistic concentrations, and recycle of solvents or catalyst where the final process will recycle them. Many teams use a miniplant, a small continuous or semi-continuous unit, to run for long enough to see impurities build up. Process safety data and a fuller cost model come in at this stage.

TRL 6, pilot trials. A pilot plant produces the product reliably in a relevant environment, often in quantities a customer can test. Some multi-step processes run each step as a separate unit at this stage. Equipment choices are made with scale-up in mind.

TRL 7, demonstration and full-scale engineering. The units are integrated into a continuous flow-through process, or a demonstration unit runs at a scale close to commercial. Start-up, shutdown and upset procedures are written, and detailed engineering for the commercial plant is done.

TRL 8, commissioning. The first commercial plant is built, commissioned and qualified. Product meets specification, and yields and producibility are at acceptable levels.

TRL 9, production. The plant runs routinely over the full range of expected conditions, and operating experience feeds improvements.

The evidence a reviewer expects at each stage

A TRL claim is only as good as the data behind it. For chemical work, reviewers and licensees look for:

  • At TRL 3: reproducible lab results across several batches, with spectra, chromatograms or property measurements, not one good run.
  • At TRL 4: a validated sequence of steps, a mass balance, and the key parameters with their ranges.
  • At TRL 5: results with technical-grade inputs, recycle data, impurity profiles over time, and process safety information.
  • At TRL 6: pilot runs with mass and energy balances, product samples tested against customer specifications, and an updated cost of production.

Our guide on how to prove your TRL gives the general evidence rules, and our post on moving from TRL 4 to TRL 6 covers the validation plan between those levels.

Where chemical scale-up breaks

Problems often appear at the step changes between scales, which is why each level should be clearly achieved before you move on.

What changes between lab and pilot scale

Lab flask
Heat removed easily
Mixing is near perfect
Fresh reagent-grade inputs
Runs for hours
vs
Pilot and plant
Heat removal can limit rate
Mixing and mass transfer matter
Technical-grade, recycled inputs
Runs for weeks, impurities build

Test the hard parts at each scale, not just the yield.

Common causes of trouble:

  • Heat and mass transfer. Surface area does not scale with volume. An exotherm that was easy to control in a flask can limit the rate in a large reactor.
  • Recycle streams. Recycling solvents or catalyst can build up trace impurities that never showed in single-pass lab work.
  • Raw material quality. Technical-grade feedstock can behave differently from the reagent-grade material used in the lab.
  • Solids handling. Filtration, drying and conveying of solids often cause more problems at scale than the reaction itself.
  • Materials consistency. For a new material, batch-to-batch consistency matters as much as the best property you achieved once.

Some teams are tempted to jump from a pilot plant straight to a commercial plant when the economics look good. It can work, but it moves the risk to a larger, more expensive plant. Plan what happens if the first plant does not perform, and how you would find the cause.

TRL and manufacturing readiness

For chemicals and materials, TRL and manufacturing readiness move together. A process at TRL 6 with no idea of where to source raw materials at scale, or how to meet a customer's specification consistently, is a weak TRL 6. Our post on MRL vs TRL explains the manufacturing readiness levels and when to use them alongside TRL.

Common mistakes

  • Calling a single good batch TRL 4. One run is a result, not a validated process.
  • Ignoring work-up and purification. The reaction may be at TRL 4 while separation is still at TRL 3. The process is only as ready as its least ready step.
  • Using reagent-grade inputs until the pilot. Switch to technical-grade earlier, at TRL 5, to find problems while they are cheap.
  • No cost model. Licensees and investors ask for cost of production at TRL 4 to 6. Keep a simple model and update it at each stage.
  • Not naming the scale. Say whether you used NTRAF or another scale.

Placing your own process

If you are unsure where your process sits, assess each step separately, then take the lowest level as the process TRL. TRL Pro gives you a structured TRL 1 to 9 assessment using Zernyx's own copyrighted framework (ZTRAF), which covers more than 60 technology domains and subdomains, so you get a level you can explain to a reviewer, a funder or a licensee.

FAQ

What TRL is a reaction that works in a round-bottom flask? Usually TRL 3, if it is reproducible and characterised. It moves to TRL 4 when the key process steps are validated together in the lab.

Is a pilot plant TRL 6 or TRL 7? Usually TRL 6. TRL 7 is a demonstration with integrated units and full-scale engineering.

Can I skip the pilot plant? It is possible but risky. Scale-up problems often appear at the step changes, and skipping a level moves the cost and risk to a larger plant.

Which TRL scale should I use in India? NTRAF for Indian funders, with a chemical-industry reading of each level. Always name the scale you used.

Dr. Abhay Tharmatt
About the author

Dr. Abhay Tharmatt

Research Scientist, R&D, Zernyx Innovations

Connect on LinkedIn
More about Dr. Abhay Tharmatt
  • Ph.D. in Pharmaceutical Sciences, BITS Pilani.

Know your TRL before a reviewer asks.

Run a guided, evidence-backed TRL 1 to 9 assessment with TRL Pro, ready for funding, licensing and commercialization decisions.

Assess with TRL Pro

Keep reading

Looking for something else?