TRL 1 meaning: basic principles observed, with examples from Indian labs
TRL 1 meaning in plain terms: basic principles observed and reported, how NASA and India's NTRAF define it, examples from lab work and the evidence needed.
Part of the guide TRL levels explained: what TRL 1 to 9 really mean, and how to place your technology
TRL 1 is the lowest technology readiness level: basic principles have been observed and reported. NASA's exit criterion is a peer-reviewed publication of the research behind the concept. India's NTRAF calls TRL 1 basic technology research and asks for a research observation report with a literature review. No application has been formulated yet; that is TRL 2.
Every technology on any readiness scale starts at TRL 1. It is the point where a scientist sees something in the lab, measures it carefully and tells the world. There is no device, no product and usually no application in mind yet. What exists is a reliable observation and a paper or report that explains it.
I spend a lot of time with research students who are unsure whether their work "counts" as TRL 1, or who rate it higher because a funder wants a bigger number. This post explains what the level means, how the main frameworks word it, what Indian lab work at this stage looks like, and what evidence a reviewer expects. For the whole scale, start with TRL levels explained.
What does TRL 1 mean?
TRL 1 means basic principles observed and reported. Three things must be true:
- You have observed a scientific effect, property or relationship.
- You can explain it with a stated principle, even a partial one.
- You have reported it, usually in a peer-reviewed paper or a documented research report.
Notice what is missing. There is no application. The moment you write "this effect could be used to make a sensor for X" and start predicting how that sensor would perform, you are at the edge of TRL 2.
How do NASA and NTRAF define TRL 1?
The two definitions most Indian researchers will meet agree on the wording and differ on the evidence.
| Framework | TRL 1 definition | Evidence asked for |
|---|---|---|
| NASA ESTO | Basic principles observed and reported | Peer-reviewed publication of research underlying the proposed concept or application |
| India, NTRAF | Basic principles observed and reported | Research observation report with supporting literature review and research findings |
Sources: NASA ESTO technology readiness levels and the National Technology Readiness Assessment Framework, published by the Office of the Principal Scientific Adviser.
NASA adds a description for hardware ("scientific knowledge generated underpinning hardware technology concepts/applications") and one for software ("scientific knowledge generated underpinning basic properties of software architecture and mathematical formulation"). NTRAF places TRL 1 in a stage it calls basic technology research and describes it as the lowest level of readiness, where scientific research begins to be translated into applied research and development.
Where TRL 1 sits on the scale
What does NTRAF check at TRL 1?
NTRAF is more demanding than a one-line definition suggests. Its Level 1 question for TRL 1 is: "Have the basic technology and principles been observed and reported?" Behind that, it lists three critical criteria, all of which must be met.
| NTRAF critical criterion | What it asks for |
|---|---|
| Paper studies confirm basic principles | Literature review and scientific papers confirming the principle |
| Research hypothesis formulated | Hypothesis formulation documentation |
| Know who cares about the technology, for example a sponsor or money source | Stakeholder identification and communication records |
The third criterion surprises people. Even at the lowest level, NTRAF wants you to know who would care. That is good discipline. It does not ask for a market study, only for evidence that someone outside your lab has an interest, which a funding agency or an industry contact can supply.
In NTRAF's scored Level 0 screening, the TRL 1 indicator reads "minimal evidence of a theoretical concept or basic principles" and carries 5 marks. A total score from 0 to 22 places a technology in the proof-of-concept band, TRL 1 to 3. NTRAF explained walks through the full scoring.
For health technologies, NTRAF's healthcare and pharmaceuticals annexure adds stage-one questions: have you identified a specific healthcare need, have the basic principles been observed and reported, and have you reviewed the scientific knowledge base as a foundation for new technologies. The evidence named includes a documented problem statement and a knowledge base assessment report.
What does TRL 1 work look like in an Indian lab?
The examples below are illustrations of the kind of work that sits at TRL 1. They are typical of what I have seen across pharmacy, chemistry and engineering departments, and none describes a specific project.
- In pharmaceutical sciences, a group finds that a new polymer forms stable nanoparticles at a certain pH and characterises them by particle size and zeta potential. They publish the observation. Nobody has yet loaded a drug.
- In materials chemistry, a researcher observes that a modified clay adsorbs fluoride from water far better than the unmodified clay, and explains it by a surface charge mechanism. The paper reports isotherms. There is no filter design.
- In plant sciences, a team reports that an extract inhibits a bacterial enzyme in a test-tube assay and proposes the compound responsible. No formulation, no animal work.
- In electronics, a thin film shows a resistance change when exposed to a gas at room temperature. The mechanism is described. No sensor circuit has been built.
- In computer science, a new mathematical property of a class of graphs is proved, suggesting faster search. No software exists.
In every case the deliverable is knowledge, and the record is a paper, a thesis chapter or a lab report. Ask yourself one question: have I proposed what this is for, with predictions? If not, you are at TRL 1.
TRL 1 or TRL 2? The same polymer, two claims
The step up is a written application with predictions.
What evidence should you keep at TRL 1?
If you may ever claim TRL 1 in a proposal, or build on the work towards a product, keep these:
- The paper or report, with raw data archived where you can find it.
- A literature review showing what was known before and what is new.
- A written hypothesis that explains the observation.
- Any correspondence with a funder, industry contact or clinician who has shown interest.
- Dated lab notebooks. They matter later for inventorship and for proving when an idea was conceived.
The last point connects to intellectual property. Under Section 3(c) of the Patents Act, 1970, "the mere discovery of a scientific principle or the formulation of an abstract theory" is not an invention, so a TRL 1 observation is rarely patentable on its own. It becomes patentable when you tie it to a specific, useful application. Be careful, though: publishing your TRL 1 paper puts the observation in the public domain, and a later patent application on the application you think of must still be new and inventive over your own paper. Talk to your institution's IPR cell before you publish anything that looks commercially interesting. Our post on what happens if you published before filing explains the risk.
Is there any commercial value at TRL 1?
Some, but less than researchers hope. A company licensing technology is buying reduced risk, and at TRL 1 almost all the risk is still there. Deals at this stage, when they happen, tend to be sponsored research or an option to license later, rather than a licence with royalties.
Illustration with invented figures. A company pays ₹3,00,000 for a one-year option over a TRL 1 result, plus ₹15,00,000 of sponsored research to reach a lab proof of concept. If the work reaches TRL 3, the option lets it take a licence on pre-agreed terms. If it does not, the company has spent ₹18,00,000 and walks away. The institution keeps the IP and the data. For how these deals are written, see option agreements.
An illustrative TRL 1 industry deal
Common mistakes at TRL 1
- Rating a published observation as TRL 3 because a grant needs it. Reviewers read the papers. An observation with no proof-of-concept experiment is TRL 1, perhaps TRL 2. Our post on overstating TRL in grant proposals covers the consequences.
- Skipping the literature review. NTRAF wants paper studies that confirm the principle. A single result with no context is weak evidence.
- Ignoring "who cares". Even one documented conversation with a potential user helps meet NTRAF's stakeholder criterion.
- Publishing first and thinking about IP later. Once the paper is out, the observation is prior art.
My own view, as a teacher: TRL 1 is a respectable place to be. Most of science lives there, and every product I have seen come out of an Indian lab started with someone recording an effect honestly. The harm comes only from calling it something it is not.
One honest caveat. The frameworks are clear at the definitions and fuzzier at the boundary with TRL 2, and two careful reviewers can place the same project differently. Where you are unsure, write down your evidence against each criterion and let the reviewer see it.
How do you check your level?
Work through the criteria above with your documents in hand, and stop at the first level where the answer is "not yet". If you want a structured check, TRL Pro assesses technology readiness from TRL 1 to 9 using Zernyx's own copyrighted framework (ZTRAF), which covers more than 60 technology domains and subdomains: you describe where your technology stands and get back an assessed TRL on the 1 to 9 scale. When the work later reaches a stage industry can use, Zernyx Hub is where companies look for technologies to license.
Common questions
What is the difference between TRL 1 and TRL 2?
TRL 1 is an observation: a scientific effect has been seen and reported. TRL 2 is an idea for using it: NASA defines it as technology concept and/or application formulated, and NTRAF as technology concept formulated. Once you can write down a specific application and predict how it should perform, you are moving into TRL 2.
Does a published paper prove TRL 1?
Usually, yes. NASA's ESTO page gives a peer-reviewed publication of the underlying research as the TRL 1 exit criterion. NTRAF asks for a research observation report with a literature review, a formulated hypothesis and some idea of who cares about the technology, such as a sponsor or funding source.
Can a TRL 1 technology be patented or licensed?
Section 3(c) of the Patents Act, 1970 excludes the mere discovery of a scientific principle, so a TRL 1 observation is rarely patentable until it is tied to a specific, useful application. Licensing at TRL 1 is uncommon; when it happens it is usually an option or a sponsored research deal.
Which funders support TRL 1 work in India?
Basic research grants from science agencies fund most TRL 1 work, and university seed grants fund some. Translational and commercialisation schemes usually expect a higher level. Check each scheme's current guideline for its entry level.