GuideTechnology transfer

How to do a prior art search before you disclose an invention: a guide for Indian faculty

A prior art search guide for Indian faculty: the free databases to use, how to build search terms, how to record results and what to send your TTO.

By Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP 7 min read
Short answer

A prior art search is a check of patents and publications to see whether your invention is already known. Before you submit an invention disclosure, spend a few hours on free databases such as the Indian Patent Office's search system, Espacenet, Google Patents and WIPO PATENTSCOPE, plus the scientific literature. Search by your invention's key features and by patent classification codes, record the closest documents and how your work differs, and send that summary to your TTO with the disclosure.

A professor submits an invention disclosure. Three weeks later the TTO comes back with a patent from 2019 that describes nearly the same thing. Nobody is at fault, but three weeks are gone, and the professor feels the work was wasted.

A few hours of searching before you disclose would have changed that. Either you would have found the 2019 patent and focused the disclosure on what is truly new, or you would have found nothing close and said so with confidence. This guide shows Indian faculty how to run that search with free tools. It is practical guidance, not legal advice, and it does not replace a professional patentability search.

The short answer

A prior art search checks patents and publications to see whether your invention is already known. Before you submit a disclosure, search free databases such as the Indian Patent Office's search system, Espacenet, Google Patents and WIPO PATENTSCOPE, plus the scientific literature. Search by your invention's key features and by patent classification codes, record the closest documents and how your work differs, and send that summary to your TTO with the disclosure.

Why search before you disclose

Indian law grants a patent only for an invention that is new and involves an inventive step. "New" is judged against what was public anywhere in the world before your filing date: patents, applications, journal papers, theses, conference talks and products. A patent does not have to come from India to block yours.

Searching early helps you in three ways. It tells you whether the core idea is already known. It shows you what is actually new in your work, so you can describe it clearly. And it gives your TTO a head start, which shortens the time to a filing decision. Our guide on writing an invention disclosure explains where the search fits in the form.

Free databases worth using

You do not need paid tools for a first search. These are free and well established:

  • Indian Patent Office search. The Indian Patent Advanced Search System, launched in 2015, offers full-text search of Indian granted patents and published applications, with Boolean operators and wildcards. Use it to see what has been filed in India and to check status.
  • Espacenet. Run by the European Patent Office, which says it offers more than 150 million patent documents from around the world. Its classification search is especially useful.
  • Google Patents. Fast full-text search across many patent offices, with machine translation and links to similar documents. Good for a first sweep.
  • WIPO PATENTSCOPE. Covers international (PCT) applications and many national collections. Useful because many important inventions are first published as PCT applications.
  • Scientific literature. Google Scholar, PubMed for life sciences, and the databases your library subscribes to. Papers are prior art too, and for academic work they are often the closest.

How to run the search, step by step

A prior art search before your disclosure

1
Write the inventionThree to five key features
2
Build search termsSynonyms, and how patents say it
3
Find class codesFrom the closest patents
4
Search patentsIndia, Espacenet, PCT
5
Search papersScholar and subject databases
6
Record the closestWhat each shows, how you differ

1. Write down what the invention is. In plain words, list three to five features that together make it work. For example: a biodegradable polymer, loaded with a specific plant extract, formed into a wound dressing, that releases the extract over 72 hours. The combination is usually what is new, not any one feature.

2. Build search terms. For each feature, list synonyms and the more formal words patents use. "Wound dressing" may appear as "wound covering", "bandage" or "topical composition". "Releases over 72 hours" may appear as "sustained release" or "controlled release". Combine terms with AND and OR, and use wildcards such as dress*.

3. Find classification codes. Once you find a few relevant patents, note their CPC or IPC classification codes. Searching by code finds documents that use different words for the same idea. This is the single biggest improvement most first-time searchers can make.

4. Search the patent databases. Start broad in Google Patents or Espacenet, then narrow using codes and feature combinations. Check Indian filings separately in the Indian Patent Office's search. Read the claims and the abstract of anything close, not just the title.

5. Search the literature. Use the same terms in Google Scholar and your subject databases. Include your own group's past papers and theses: your own earlier publication can be prior art against you. Our post on what happens if you published before filing explains why.

6. Record what you find. Keep a short table. For each close document: its number or citation, date, what it discloses, and which of your features it does not have.

How to record the results

A simple table is enough, and your TTO will thank you for it.

Document Date What it shows What it lacks compared with ours
Patent A (number) 2019 Polymer dressing with plant extract No sustained release, extract differs
Paper B (citation) 2022 Same extract, antibacterial activity Not a dressing, no polymer carrier
Patent C (number) 2021 Sustained-release dressing Synthetic drug, not a plant extract

This example is made up, but it shows the idea. If no single document has all your features, say so. If one comes very close, say that too: it is far better to know now.

Limits you should know

  • Recent applications are invisible. In India, an application is kept from public view for 18 months from its filing or priority date, unless early publication is requested. Most countries follow a similar rule. No search can find what has not been published yet.
  • Free tools miss things. Coverage, especially of older and non-English documents, varies between databases. That is why you use several.
  • Combinations are hard to judge. Even if no document has all your features, an examiner may combine two documents to argue your invention is obvious. Leave that judgement to a professional.
  • Keep it confidential. Searching does not disclose your invention, but do not paste unpublished details into online tools whose terms you have not read, and do not discuss the search findings in public.

Your own search vs a professional search

Your own search
Free databases, a few hours
Finds obvious overlaps early
Sharpens what is new
Speeds up the TTO decision
vs
Professional search
Done before filing
Wider coverage and classification
Judges novelty and inventive step
Shapes the claims

Do yours first. It makes the professional one faster and cheaper.

What to send your TTO

Attach a one-page search summary to your disclosure: the search terms and codes you used, the databases searched, the date of the search, the closest three to five documents in a table, and a short paragraph on what is new in your work. The TTO can then decide faster, brief the patent agent better and, later, describe the technology to industry. Our guide on writing a non-confidential summary shows how the same "what is new" paragraph becomes the core of your pitch to companies.

Faculty often find this framing step the hardest part: what exactly is new, and who would care. TT Co-Pilot, Zernyx's AI assistant for technology transfer, built for TTO teams and university faculty on Zernyx's proprietary technology licensing dataset, can help you think through how to describe your invention and its likely uses before you meet your TTO.

Common mistakes

  • Searching only for your exact words. Patents use different language. Use synonyms and classification codes.
  • Searching only Indian patents. Novelty is judged worldwide.
  • Forgetting papers and theses. Including your own.
  • Stopping at the title. Read the abstract and claims of anything close.
  • Treating "nothing found" as proof. It is a good sign, not a guarantee.

FAQ

Why should faculty search before submitting an invention disclosure?

Because novelty is judged against everything published anywhere before your filing date. A short search shows whether your idea is already known and helps your TTO decide faster.

The Indian Patent Office's public search system, Espacenet, Google Patents and WIPO PATENTSCOPE, plus Google Scholar and subject databases for papers.

Can a search miss recent patent applications?

Yes. Applications are usually kept from public view for 18 months from filing or priority, so recent filings cannot be found.

No. It helps you decide early and describe the invention well. A patent agent or search professional usually runs a fuller search before filing.

Sahil Sheikh
About the author

Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP

Chief IP & Technology Officer, Zernyx Innovations

Connect on LinkedIn

Find a technology you can own.

Search patented technologies from Indian universities and labs, check their readiness and license the right one on Zernyx Hub.

Explore Zernyx Hub

Keep reading

Looking for something else?