GuidePatents

Pre-grant opposition in India: what a university TTO should do when its patent application is opposed

Pre-grant opposition in India for universities: Section 25(1) grounds, the Rule 55 steps, the 2-month reply deadline, Form 7A fees and how a TTO should respond.

By Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP 7 min read
Short answer

Any person can file a pre-grant opposition against an Indian patent application after it is published and before it is granted, on the grounds in Section 25(1) of the Patents Act. Since the 2024 amendment to Rule 55, the Controller first decides whether the representation makes a prima facie case. If it does, the university as applicant gets a notice and has 2 months to file its reply statement and evidence, after which the Controller hears the parties if asked and decides.

Most university patent applications in India move quietly: filing, publication, examination, a First Examination Report, a reply, grant. Now and then, a letter arrives from the Patent Office saying someone has filed a representation opposing the grant. For a small IPR cell, this can feel alarming. It is a routine part of Indian patent law, with a fixed procedure and short deadlines.

This guide explains what pre-grant opposition is, how the procedure works since the 2024 rule changes, what it costs and what a university TTO should do, step by step.

The short answer

Under Section 25(1) of the Patents Act, any person can oppose a published application before it is granted. Since 15 March 2024, under the amended Rule 55, the Controller first checks whether the representation makes a prima facie case. If not, it is refused. If it does, the applicant (your university) gets a notice and has 2 months to file a reply statement and evidence. The Controller then hears the parties if asked and passes one order on the application and the opposition together.

Who can oppose, and when

Pre-grant opposition can be filed by any person, at any time after the application is published and before the patent is granted. The opponent does not need to show an interest. In practice, opponents are usually competitors, generic manufacturers, public interest groups or companies that want to use the technology freely.

Two timing rules matter for a university:

  • No grant before six months from publication (Rule 55(1A)). This gives the public a window to oppose.
  • The representation is considered only after a request for examination is filed (Rule 55(2)). If your Form 18 is not filed, the opposition waits.

The Controller General's annual report for 2022-23 shows 420 pre-grant oppositions filed that year, against 800 in 2019-20. It is not common, but it is not rare either.

The grounds an opponent can use

Section 25(1) lists the grounds, and an opponent cannot go outside them:

  • (a) The invention was wrongfully obtained from the opponent.
  • (b) Prior publication anywhere before the priority date.
  • (c) Prior claiming in an earlier Indian application.
  • (d) Public knowledge or use in India before the priority date.
  • (e) Obviousness, or lack of inventive step.
  • (f) Not an invention, or not patentable (for example under Section 3).
  • (g) Insufficient or unclear description.
  • (h) Failure to disclose, or false information, under Section 8 (foreign filings).
  • (i) A convention application not filed within 12 months.
  • (j) Source or geographical origin of biological material not disclosed or wrong.
  • (k) Anticipation by traditional or community knowledge.

For universities, three grounds come up again and again. Prior publication (b), because faculty publish papers, theses and conference posters, sometimes before filing. Section 8 (h), because university IPR cells often miss updating Form 3 after a PCT or foreign filing. And inventive step (e), the most common ground across all applications. Our guide on publishing before filing explains the publication risk.

The procedure under Rule 55, step by step

Pre-grant opposition under Rule 55

1
Form 7A filedOpponent files, with a copy to you
2
Prima facie checkController decides within 1 month
3
Notice to youIf there is a prima facie case
4
Your replyStatement and evidence in 2 months
5
HearingIf either party asks
6
DecisionOne order on both
  1. The opponent files Form 7A with a statement and evidence, and sends you a copy. They can ask to be heard.
  2. The Controller considers it once your request for examination is on file.
  3. Prima facie check. If there is no prima facie case, the Controller notifies the opponent and refuses the representation, within one month of that notice or of a hearing if the opponent asks for one. If there is a prima facie case, the Controller passes a reasoned order within one month of receiving the representation and notifies you.
  4. Your reply. Under Rule 55(4) you may file a statement and evidence within 2 months of the notice, with a copy to the opponent.
  5. Hearing. If asked, the Controller hears the parties.
  6. Decision. Under Rule 55(5) the Controller either rejects the representation, requires the specification to be amended, or refuses the patent. It is one speaking order on the application and the representation, ordinarily within one month of the proceedings ending.

The application is also examined on an expedited basis once an opposition is on file (Rule 55(5B)), so the whole matter can move faster than normal examination.

The deadline that matters most

The 2-month reply window is short, and it runs alongside your normal prosecution deadlines. If you also have a pending FER, both can be live at once.

Key dates once an opposition is filed

PublicationOpposition window opensNo grant for 6 months from here
Filing + 1 monthPrima facie orderController decides if there is a case
Notice + 2 monthsYour reply dueStatement and evidence
After hearingDecisionOrdinarily within 1 month

Enter the notice date in your docket the day it arrives. Count two months from the notice, not from the opponent's filing date.

What it costs

From the First Schedule of the Patents Rules (electronic filing):

Item Educational institution, startup, small entity, natural person Others
Form 7A, pre-grant representation (paid by the opponent) ₹4,000 ₹20,000
Form 7, post-grant opposition (paid by the opponent) ₹8,000 ₹40,000
Adjournment of a hearing, each ₹1,000 ₹5,000

As the applicant, your main cost is not official fees. It is the patent agent's time for the reply statement, and often an expert affidavit from the inventor or an independent scientist on inventive step.

How a university TTO should respond

1. Read the representation the day it arrives. List each ground and each document the opponent relies on.

2. Check your own record. Pull the inventors' publications, theses and conference abstracts, and your Form 3 history. If the opponent cites your own professor's paper, you need to know its date against your priority date.

3. Brief the inventor. The inventor knows the prior art better than anyone. Ask for a written note on how each cited document differs from the claims.

4. Decide on amendments. If a prior art document is close, narrowing the claims can save the application. A narrower granted patent is worth more than a broad refused one, especially if a licensee is waiting.

5. File the reply within 2 months. Address every ground. Attach evidence: expert affidavits, experimental data, publication dates.

6. Ask for a hearing. It gives your agent a chance to answer the Controller's questions directly.

7. Tell your licensee or partner. If the technology is licensed or under option, the agreement may require you to inform them. An opposition affects their plans too.

Pre-grant or post-grant: the difference

Pre-grant and post-grant opposition

Pre-grant
Any person
After publication, before grant
Form 7A, ₹4,000 or ₹20,000
Decided by the Controller
vs
Post-grant
Any person interested
Within 1 year of grant
Form 7, ₹8,000 or ₹40,000
Opposition Board, then Controller

Surviving a pre-grant opposition does not stop a post-grant one. Any person interested can still oppose within one year of the grant being published.

Common mistakes

  • Missing the 2-month deadline because the notice went to the inventor's department, not the IPR cell.
  • Not replying, on the view that the opponent's case is weak. The Controller still decides on the evidence before them.
  • Defending claims that cannot be saved instead of amending.
  • Ignoring Form 3. Section 8 is an easy ground. Keep foreign filing details up to date.
  • Losing the file trail. Oppositions often turn on dates. Keep every publication, disclosure and filing date in one place.

A system that holds every application's dates, notices and documents together makes these deadlines much easier to meet. Zernyx IPMS is built for universities and research institutions to manage patents, filings and portfolios end to end. For the normal examination stage, see our guide on responding to a First Examination Report.

FAQ

Who can file a pre-grant opposition in India? Any person, after publication and before grant.

How long does a university have to reply? Two months from the Controller's notice under Rule 55(4).

What does Form 7A cost? ₹4,000 for educational institutions, startups, small entities and natural persons, and ₹20,000 for others.

Can the patent be granted while the opposition is pending? No. The Controller decides the application and the opposition in one order.

Does winning a pre-grant opposition prevent a later challenge? No. A post-grant opposition can still be filed within one year of grant, and revocation remains possible later.

Sahil Sheikh
About the author

Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP

Chief IP & Technology Officer, Zernyx Innovations

Connect on LinkedIn

Manage every patent in one place.

Zernyx IPMS is an IP management system to manage patents, filings and IP portfolios end to end.

Explore Zernyx IPMS

Keep reading

Looking for something else?