# Patent portfolio review for universities: which patents to keep, license or let go

URL: https://zernyxhub.com/blog/patent-portfolio-review-university
Author: Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP
Published: 2026-10-24
Category: Patents

> Patent portfolio review for Indian universities: what each patent costs to keep, how to score it, when to license or let it lapse, and Section 63 surrender.

**Short answer:** A university patent portfolio review is a yearly check of every granted patent and pending application to decide whether to keep paying for it, push it harder for licensing, or let it go. Score each one on licensing interest, technology readiness, remaining life, cost to keep and strategic value, and decide before the next renewal falls due. In India a patent can be dropped by not paying the renewal fee, or surrendered formally under Section 63, which has no official fee but is published and can be opposed within three months.

Most Indian universities file more patents every year and drop almost none. That feels safe, but it is not free. Each granted patent costs renewal fees every year, a working statement every three years and staff time to track it all. A portfolio of a few hundred patents can quietly absorb a large part of an IPR cell's budget, much of it on inventions no company will ever license.

A portfolio review fixes that. Once a year, you look at every patent and application and make a deliberate decision: keep it, push it harder for licensing, or let it go. This guide gives a method an IPR cell or technology transfer office can run, with the Indian rules and costs behind each decision. It is practical guidance, not legal advice, and your institute's IP policy decides who signs off.

## The short answer

Review every granted patent and pending application at least once a year, and decide each one before its next renewal fee falls due. Score it on five things: **licensing interest, technology readiness, remaining life, cost to keep and strategic value**. Keep the patents that score well, set a licensing plan with a deadline for those in the middle, and let go of the rest. In India, you can drop a patent by not paying the renewal fee, or surrender it formally under **Section 63**, which has no official fee but is published and can be opposed within **three months**.

## What each patent costs to keep

Start with the money, because it makes the decision concrete. Since the Patents (Amendment) Rules, 2021, educational institutions pay the same lower fees as natural persons, startups and small entities. Annual renewal fees from the First Schedule:

| Patent year | Educational institution |
|---|---|
| 3rd to 6th | ₹800 a year |
| 7th to 10th | ₹2,400 a year |
| 11th to 15th | ₹4,800 a year |
| 16th to 20th | ₹8,000 a year |

Kept for the full 20 years, one Indian patent costs ₹76,800 in official renewal fees, and more than half of that falls in the last five years. Our guide to [patent renewal in India](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/patent-renewal-india) covers due dates, the six-month extension and restoration in detail.

**A worked example.** A patent is entering its 12th year. Keeping it to full term means four more years at ₹4,800 (₹19,200) and five years at ₹8,000 (₹40,000): ₹59,200 in official fees alone. Add professional fees for docketing, payment and the working statement. If the same invention is also patented abroad, the foreign annuities are usually much higher. For a portfolio of 200 patents, small numbers add up quickly.

There is one saving to plan for. Since the Patents (Amendment) Rules, 2024, paying renewal fees electronically in advance for at least four years earns a 10% reduction on those fees. Use it for the patents you are sure about, never for the doubtful ones.

## The five questions for each patent

Score each patent from 1 to 3 on each question. Keep the scoring simple enough that two people in your office would score the same patent the same way.

1. **Licensing interest.** Has any company asked about it, signed an NDA, taken an option or licensed it? Is there a market you can name?
2. **Technology readiness.** Is the invention still at lab proof of concept, or is there a prototype or validated data? Companies license tested technology far more readily.
3. **Remaining life.** How many years are left? A strong patent with three years left may be worth less than a moderate one with fifteen.
4. **Cost to keep.** Renewal fees ahead, foreign annuities and any prosecution still to come.
5. **Strategic value.** Is it core to an active research group, a faculty startup, a sponsored project or a funder's requirement? Does it protect a platform other patents depend on?

Then sort the results into three groups.

- **Keep (high scores):** pay renewals, consider the four-year advance payment and keep the Form 27 record clean.
- **Push (middle scores):** set a licensing plan with a named owner and a deadline, usually before the next renewal. Prepare a non-confidential summary, reach out to a defined list of companies and review again at the deadline.
- **Let go (low scores):** decide how to end it, check every obligation first, and record the reason.

**A yearly patent portfolio review**
1. List every case: Patents, applications and deadlines
2. Add the cost to keep: Renewals ahead, foreign annuities
3. Score five questions: Interest, TRL, life, cost, strategy
4. Sort into three groups: Keep, push or let go
5. Check obligations: Licences, co-owners, funders, inventors
6. Act before renewal: Record each decision and reason

## Check obligations before you drop anything

A patent you no longer want can still be one someone else depends on. Before you let any patent go, check:

- **Licences and options.** Many licences require the licensor to maintain the patent, or to offer it to the licensee before abandoning it. Read the agreement. If a licence is registered, the licensee's interest is on the register.
- **Co-owners.** A patent co-owned with a company or another institution needs a joint decision. Your co-ownership agreement should say who pays and what happens if one owner wants out.
- **Sponsors and funders.** Sponsored research and grant terms sometimes say who must be told before IP is abandoned. Read the agreement for each funded patent.
- **Inventors.** Some policies give inventors the chance to take over a patent the institution plans to drop. Check yours, and ask before you decide.
- **Faculty startups.** A patent may be the foundation of a startup's licence. Talk to the founders first.

If your [university IP policy](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/university-ip-policy) does not yet say who decides on abandonment and who must be consulted, add it.

## Two ways to let a patent go

**1. Let it lapse.** Do not pay the next renewal fee. The patent ceases to have effect once the due date and the six-month extension pass. It is simple and costs nothing, but it is not final straight away: under Section 60 the patentee can apply on Form 15 within 18 months of the lapse to restore it, if the failure to pay was unintentional. A deliberate decision to stop paying is unlikely to meet that test, so record it as deliberate.

**2. Surrender it under Section 63.** The patentee gives notice to the Controller offering to surrender the patent. The First Schedule lists no fee for this notice. The Controller publishes the offer and notifies anyone recorded in the register as having an interest. Under Rule 87, any interested person can oppose on Form 14 within three months of publication. If the Controller accepts, the patent is revoked by order and the revocation is published.

Most universities simply let unwanted patents lapse. Surrender is useful when you want a clear public record that the patent has ended, for example because a licensee or co-owner has agreed to it, or because you want to stop all future obligations in an orderly way.

**Letting a patent lapse or surrendering it**
Let it lapse:
- Stop paying the renewal fee
- No filing needed
- Can be restored within 18 months
- Quiet, no publication
Surrender, Section 63:
- Notice to the Controller
- No official fee
- Published, opposable for 3 months
- Ends in revocation by order
Check licences, co-owners and funders before either.

## Review pending applications too

The biggest savings often come before grant. Review each application at the points where the next cost is large:

- **Before requesting examination.** If no company has shown interest and the invention is far from use, ask whether to continue at all.
- **At the 12-month priority deadline.** Deciding whether to file a complete specification or a PCT application is a portfolio decision, not a formality. Our guide to [PCT filing for universities](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/pct-filing-university) covers the 31-month national phase choice.
- **When responding to an examination report.** If the claims will be narrowed to the point of having no commercial value, a costly response may not be worth it.

## Keep the record

Every decision needs a short written record: the scores, the reason, who approved it and the date. It protects the office when an inventor asks why a patent was dropped, and it builds a history that makes next year's review faster. It also feeds the Form 27 working statement, which every patentee files for each block of three financial years. Our post on [Form 27](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/form-27-working-statement) explains the current deadlines.

## Common mistakes

- **Deciding after the deadline.** A missed renewal becomes a decision you did not take. Review well before each due date.
- **Keeping everything "just in case".** Spend on the patents with a real licensing path, not on all of them equally.
- **Dropping a licensed patent.** Always check the licence, co-owners and funders first.
- **Scoring by citation count.** Academic impact and licensing value are different things.
- **No owner for the "push" group.** A licensing plan without a named person and a deadline usually does nothing.

## Tools that make the review repeatable

A review only works if the data is current: every case, its deadlines, its costs, its licences and its history in one place. Many IPR cells start with a spreadsheet and outgrow it as the portfolio grows. Zernyx IPMS is an IP lifecycle management platform for universities and research institutions to manage patents, filings and IP portfolios end to end. You can use [Zernyx IPMS](https://ipms.zernyxhub.com/) to keep each patent's deadlines, costs and decisions together so the yearly review becomes routine.

## FAQ

### How often should a university review its patents?

At least once a year, with each decision made before the next renewal falls due. Also review applications before the request for examination, at the 12-month priority deadline and before national phase entry.

### What is the cheapest way to drop an Indian patent?

Not paying the renewal fee costs nothing. Formal surrender under Section 63 also has no official fee in the First Schedule, but it is published and can be opposed within three months.

### Can a lapsed patent come back?

Yes, within 18 months under Section 60, through an application on Form 15, but only if the Controller accepts that the failure to pay was unintentional. A recorded, deliberate decision to stop paying is unlikely to meet that test.

### Who should approve dropping a patent?

Whoever your IP policy names, usually an IP committee with the TTO head and a faculty representative. Consult the inventors, co-owners, licensees and funders before the decision.

---

Published by Zernyx Hub. More: https://zernyxhub.com/llms.txt
