JournalTechnology readiness

NTRAF vs NASA TRL compared, and where ZTRAF fits

NTRAF vs NASA TRL compared level by level, and where ZTRAF, Zernyx's own TRL framework covering more than 60 technology domains, fits in a proposal.

By Dr. Deepak Chitkara, Founder, Zernyx Innovations 7 min read

Part of the guide TRL levels explained: what TRL 1 to 9 really mean, and how to place your technology

Short answer

NTRAF keeps NASA's nine TRL levels but rewrites them for any sector and adds a 150-point screening, a named report per level and critical criteria. ZTRAF, Zernyx's own copyrighted framework used in TRL Pro, is aligned with global standards and covers more than 60 technology domains and subdomains.

Every Indian researcher who has written a grant proposal knows the NASA scale, even if they never read the original. TRL 1 to 9 came into Indian proposals through international practice and through agencies such as BIRAC, which adapted it for its own sectors. The National Technology Readiness Assessment Framework, NTRAF, now gives India its own version.

A common question is whether NTRAF is a new scale or the old one renamed. It is the same nine levels with different wording and, more importantly, a different method of deciding which level you are at. This post sets the two side by side so you can see what changes for your proposal. For a full explanation of NTRAF itself, read NTRAF explained.

Where do the two frameworks come from?

NASA's definitions are published by its Earth Science Technology Office, on the ESTO TRL page, and in a NASA definitions sheet with exit criteria for each level. They were written for space and flight hardware.

NTRAF is the Office of the Principal Scientific Adviser's framework, developed with the Confederation of Indian Industry and unveiled by PSA Ajay Kumar Sood in December 2025, with public consultation open until 31 January 2026. The framework document says plainly that "TRL was developed by NASA", and that its own definitions are adapted from the European Union, the US Department of Energy and the US Department of Defense. It describes itself as "an initial proposal of guidelines".

Level by level: what does each framework say?

TRL NASA (ESTO) NTRAF
1 Basic principles observed and reported Basic principles observed and reported
2 Technology concept and/or application formulated Technology concept formulated
3 Analytical and experimental critical function and/or characteristic proof of concept Experimental proof of concept
4 Component and/or breadboard validation in laboratory environment Component and/or system validation in lab
5 Component and/or breadboard validation in relevant environment Laboratory scale, similar system validation in relevant environment
6 System/sub-system model or prototype demonstration (environment wording varies; see below) Engineering/pilot-scale prototype demonstrated in relevant environment
7 System prototype demonstration in an operational environment Full scale system prototype demonstration in operational environment
8 Actual system completed and "flight qualified" through test and demonstration System complete and qualified through test and demonstration
9 Actual system "flight proven" through successful mission operations Actual system proven in operational environment over full range of expected conditions

Read down the right-hand column and three changes stand out.

  1. Scale words. NTRAF tells you how big the thing should be: laboratory scale at TRL 5, engineering or pilot scale at TRL 6, full scale at TRL 7. NASA's wording speaks of breadboards and prototypes, with scale implied.
  2. No flight or space language. "Flight qualified" and "flight proven" become "qualified" and "proven in operational environment over full range of expected conditions". A food process or a diagnostic kit can now be described without translating from aerospace.
  3. TRL 6 is fixed in a relevant environment. NASA's own wording for TRL 6 is not consistent: on the ESTO page, the short definition refers to an operational environment, while the longer description speaks of a relevant environment. NTRAF removes the doubt.

NTRAF's five stages across the nine levels

TRL 9System operations
TRL 8System commissioning
TRL 7System commissioning
Technology demonstration
TRL 6Technology demonstration
TRL 5Technology demonstration
TRL 4Technology demonstration
TRL 3Research to prove feasibility
TRL 2Research to prove feasibility
TRL 1Basic technology research
Stage names as given in the NTRAF document.

How does the method of assessment differ?

This is the bigger change, and the one proposal writers tend to miss.

NASA gives each level an exit criterion: a documented result you must have to claim the level. For TRL 4, for example, "Documented test performance demonstrating agreement with analytical predictions" plus a "Documented definition of relevant environment". It is a scale with evidence attached, and the assessor judges whether the evidence is enough.

NTRAF turns that judgement into three steps:

Step What happens What it produces
1. Screening Level 0 questions scored out of 150 A band: 0 to 22 proof of concept, 23 to 70 prototype, 70 to 150 manufacturing or commercialisation
2. Anticipated TRL Yes or no questions for each level, each yes backed by a named report The highest level answered yes with documents
3. Critical criteria All critical criteria for the target level and below must be yes A confirmed TRL, or the level below (TRL n-1)

Two details matter in practice. First, each level names its supporting document; TRL 1 asks for a "Research Observation Report with supporting Literature Review and Research Findings", and TRL 9 for an "Operational Environment Testing Report". Second, the n-1 rule is strict. One missing critical item, or one missing document, and you drop a level. (The document's bands put the score of 70 in two bands; I would read the boundary with the funder if your score lands there.)

NTRAF also asks for separate assessments of each Critical Technology Element, meaning a technology element that is new or novel. NASA practice and the US GAO's technology readiness guide work with critical technologies too, so this idea is shared. What NTRAF adds is the sector annexures: Annexure A for healthcare and pharmaceuticals, which brings in animal studies, DCGI submissions and clinical phases, and Annexure B for software, which brings in alpha and beta testing, security audits and data privacy.

Claiming TRL 6 under each framework

NASA style
Prototype demonstration
Exit criterion: test results match predictions
Assessor judges sufficiency
vs
NTRAF
Pilot-scale prototype in relevant environment
Named report for each yes
Any critical no means TRL 5

NTRAF is less forgiving of missing documents.

Which one should you use?

The practical rule is simple: use the scale the reader of your document uses.

Situation Use Why
Indian call or mission that names NTRAF NTRAF, with its reports The assessor will apply the n-1 rule
BIRAC scheme BIRAC's own sector definitions See TRL for BIRAC SBIRI and BIPP
ANRF proposal with a TRL field The call's own definition, else NTRAF See how to state TRL in an ANRF proposal
Foreign partner or space agency NASA or that agency's scale Their reviewers know it
Licensing talk with an Indian company NTRAF wording, with evidence Plain, sector-neutral and Indian

I should add a hedge. NTRAF is still described as an initial proposal, and the PSA invited comments on it, so details such as the screening bands could change. Check the current document before you submit.

What should you change in your proposal?

  • State which framework you used, by name.
  • For each claimed level, list the document that supports it, using NTRAF's report names where NTRAF applies.
  • Say the scale of your prototype. "Pilot scale, 20 litres" means something under NTRAF that "prototype" does not.
  • Assess each novel element separately if your technology has more than one.
  • Do not mix wording. A BIRAC form filled with NTRAF definitions, or the reverse, confuses reviewers. TRL levels explained covers this common mistake, and how to prove your TRL lists the evidence.

Where does ZTRAF fit?

NASA and NTRAF are public scales, and you will still name one of them in your proposal when the funder asks for it. ZTRAF stands for Zernyx Technology Readiness Assessment Framework. It is Zernyx's own copyrighted framework, aligned with global standards and separate from NTRAF, and it is what TRL Pro uses to assess a technology from TRL 1 to 9.

ZTRAF covers more than 60 technology domains and subdomains, because a TRL 5 claim means something different for a vaccine, a battery chemistry, a crop variety and a software platform. In TRL Pro you answer structured questions with your evidence and get back an assessed level, the gaps to close and the next steps, with a Zernyx certificate.

Use them together. Run your technology through TRL Pro for a ZTRAF assessment first, then state the level in your proposal in the wording your funder names, NTRAF or NASA, with the evidence listed above.

Common questions

Is NTRAF based on the NASA TRL scale?

Yes, in origin. The NTRAF document says TRL was developed by NASA as a metric to assess maturity, and that its own definitions are adapted from the European Union, the US Department of Energy and the US Department of Defense. It keeps nine levels with the same broad meaning.

What is the biggest difference between NTRAF and NASA TRL?

The method. NASA's definitions are a scale with exit criteria for each level. NTRAF adds a three-step assessment: a screening score out of 150, an anticipated TRL backed by a named supporting report, and critical criteria. If any critical criterion for a level is answered no, the technology is pegged at the next lower level.

Should an Indian researcher use NTRAF or the NASA scale?

Use the scale your funder or partner names. NTRAF calls itself an initial proposal of guidelines for funding organisations and research institutes. Where an Indian call asks for NTRAF, use it; where a foreign partner or a sector scheme such as BIRAC's uses its own definitions, follow those.

Does NTRAF use the words relevant environment and operational environment?

Yes. NTRAF puts TRL 5 and TRL 6 in a relevant environment and TRL 7 in an operational environment, with TRL 9 proven in an operational environment over the full range of expected conditions.

What is ZTRAF?

ZTRAF, the Zernyx Technology Readiness Assessment Framework, is Zernyx's own copyrighted framework, aligned with global standards and used in TRL Pro. It keeps the familiar TRL 1 to 9 levels and covers more than 60 technology domains and subdomains. It is separate from NTRAF, so if a funder asks for NTRAF or NASA wording, state your level in that wording.

Dr. Deepak Chitkara
About the author

Dr. Deepak Chitkara

Founder, Zernyx Innovations

Connect on LinkedInWatch on YouTube
More about Dr. Deepak Chitkara
  • Professor, Department of Pharmacy, BITS Pilani.
  • Has coordinated the Intellectual Property Enablement and Commercialization (IPEC) division at BITS Pilani.
  • Has served as Coordinator of the BITS-Technology Enabling Center, supported by the Department of Science and Technology (DST), Government of India.

Know your TRL before a reviewer asks.

Run a guided, evidence-backed TRL 1 to 9 assessment with TRL Pro, ready for funding, licensing and commercialization decisions.

Assess with TRL Pro

Keep reading

Looking for something else?