# NTRAF explained: India's national TRL framework and how to self-assess

URL: https://zernyxhub.com/blog/ntraf-explained
Author: Dr. Deepak Chitkara, Founder, Zernyx Innovations
Published: 2026-10-27
Category: Technology readiness

> NTRAF explained: what India's National Technology Readiness Assessment Framework says, its nine levels, the evidence each needs and how to self-assess.

**Short answer:** NTRAF, the National Technology Readiness Assessment Framework, is the Office of the Principal Scientific Adviser's common method for rating technology readiness from TRL 1 to 9. It was developed with CII and unveiled in December 2025. Assessment has three tiers: a scored screening, an anticipated TRL backed by a named report, and critical criteria that must all be met.

Until recently, "TRL 5" on an Indian proposal could mean different things to different ministries, missions and funders, because each used its own modified TRL definitions. The National Technology Readiness Assessment Framework, or NTRAF, is the government's attempt to give the whole system one measuring stick.

This explainer sets out what the official document from the Office of the Principal Scientific Adviser (PSA) actually says, and how to self-assess against it. If the TRL scale itself is new to you, read [TRL levels explained](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/trl-levels-explained) first.

## What is NTRAF?

NTRAF is a standard method for measuring how mature a technology is, from TRL 1 (basic principles observed) to TRL 9 (actual system proven in operation). The [PSA's NTRAF page](https://psa.gov.in/national-technology-readiness) says it harmonises definitions and assessment criteria so that projects can be compared across national missions. The framework document itself says its aim is to "objectively measure the maturity and associated risks" of technical project proposals.

Two features set it apart from a plain TRL table. First, every level has a named report you must be able to produce. Second, every level has critical criteria, and a single "no" drops you a level.

## Who published NTRAF, and is it final?

The framework comes from the Office of the Principal Scientific Adviser to the Government of India, developed in consultation with the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) and a group of experts from industry, academia and research labs. Professor Ajay Kumar Sood, the Principal Scientific Adviser, unveiled it at the end of December 2025, and a [News On AIR report](https://www.newsonair.gov.in/principal-scientific-adviser-ajay-kumar-sood-unveils-national-technology-readiness-assessment-framework) said it was open for public comment until 31 January 2026.

The status needs care. The [framework document](https://psa.gov.in/CMS/web/sites/default/files/publication/National%20Technology%20Readiness%20Assessment%20Framework_Final.pdf) carries no version number or date and describes itself as "an initial proposal of guidelines". The PSA page, last updated on 24 October 2026, still invites comments on the draft. Check it before you quote NTRAF wording in a proposal.

## Why does India need one TRL framework?

The executive summary names the problem plainly: optimism bias, where perceived readiness runs ahead of the real engineering status. A team with a good paper and a bench rig writes TRL 6 because the call asks for TRL 6, and nobody has a shared yardstick to push back with.

NTRAF also signals a shift in what funders reward, from output-based reporting such as publications to outcome-based progress such as validated systems. The document calls itself the technical backbone as national efforts scale up through the Anusandhan National Research Foundation (ANRF) and other deep-tech programmes.

In my view, this shift matters more than the level definitions. Researchers respond to what they are measured on, and a named report at every level makes inflated claims costly.

## The nine NTRAF levels and their stages

NTRAF keeps the familiar nine levels and groups them into five stages.

| TRL | NTRAF stage | NTRAF definition |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Basic technology research | Basic principles observed and reported |
| 2 | Research to prove feasibility | Technology concept formulated |
| 3 | Research to prove feasibility | Experimental proof of concept |
| 4 | Technology demonstration | Component and/or system validation in lab |
| 5 | Technology demonstration | Laboratory scale, similar system validation in relevant environment |
| 6 | Technology demonstration | Engineering/pilot-scale prototype demonstrated in relevant environment |
| 7 | System commissioning | Full scale system prototype demonstration in operational environment |
| 8 | System commissioning | System complete and qualified through test and demonstration |
| 9 | System operations | Actual system proven in operational environment over full range of expected conditions |

**The nine NTRAF levels**
- TRL 1: Basic principles observed and reported
- TRL 2: Technology concept formulated
- TRL 3: Experimental proof of concept
- TRL 4: Component or system validated in the lab
- TRL 5: Lab-scale system validated in relevant environment
- TRL 6: Pilot-scale prototype in relevant environment
- TRL 7: Full-scale prototype in operational environment
- TRL 8: System complete and qualified
- TRL 9: Proven over the full range of conditions
(Technology demonstration: TRL 4 to TRL 6)

The document describes TRL 4 to 6 as "the bridge from scientific research to engineering", and TRL 6 as the step up from laboratory scale to engineering scale. It defines a relevant environment as a testing environment that simulates the key aspects of the operational environment. Our guides on [moving from TRL 4 to TRL 6](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/trl-4-to-trl-6) and [from TRL 6 to TRL 9](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/trl-6-to-trl-9) go level by level.

## How does an NTRAF assessment work?

Before any questions, NTRAF asks you to identify the Critical Technology Elements (CTEs) of the project: elements that are new or novel and critical to its success. Section 3.2 says this should happen before the first TRL review, preferably at the start. Each CTE gets its own assessment. Then come three tiers.

**Step 1, Level 0 pre-assessment (Section 3.3).** Nine indicators carry marks from 5 to 30, totalling 150. The total places you in a band: 0 to 22 is the proof-of-concept stage (TRL 1 to 3), 23 to 70 is prototype development (TRL 4 to 6), and 70 to 150 is manufacturing and commercialisation (TRL 7 to 9). Note that the published bands both include 70.

The document does not spell out the scoring rule, but the marks are cumulative in effect: the first three indicators add up to 22, the first six to 70, and all nine to 150, which matches the band edges. Read that way, a team that can honestly claim the first five indicators (minimal evidence of principles, 5; initial feasibility analysis, 7; clear proof of concept, 10; early-stage development, 12; ongoing development with a functional prototype, 16) scores 50 and lands in the prototype development band.

**Step 2, Level 1 anticipated TRL (Section 3.4).** One top-level question per level, asked from TRL 9 downwards or from TRL 1 upwards. For TRL 6 it reads: "Has the engineering/pilot-scale prototype been demonstrated in relevant environment?" The highest level answered yes, with supporting documentation, becomes the Anticipated TRL.

**Step 3, Level 2 verification (Section 3.5).** Detailed criteria, grouped as Technology (T), Manufacturing (M) and Programmatic/Quality (P), with critical items marked Y. Section 3.5 says to begin one level below the Anticipated TRL. All critical criteria for the target level and below must be yes. If they are, the project is certified at that TRL. If any is no, or its document is missing, the project is pegged at TRL n-1 and you repeat the check one level down. The assessment is then submitted for review.

**How an NTRAF assessment reaches a TRL**
Critical Technology Element:
1. Level 0 screening: Nine indicators, 150 marks, gives a TRL band
2. Level 1 questions: Highest yes with a report is the Anticipated TRL
3. Level 2 criteria: All critical items yes, or drop to TRL n-1
4. Review: Assessment submitted for review
Result: Certified TRL

## What evidence does each NTRAF level need?

Each Level 1 question names a supporting report, and Level 2 lists the critical criteria behind it. The table gives a selection; the full questionnaire in the PSA document has more items, so work from the original.

| TRL | Report NTRAF expects | Critical criteria include |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Research observation report, with literature review | Basic principles confirmed by paper studies, research hypothesis formulated |
| 2 | Technical solution formulation document | Applications identified, performance predictions documented, a rough idea of how to market the technology |
| 3 | Proof of concept simulation report | Predictions validated by analysis or experiment, performance metrics set, scaling studies started |
| 4 | Component/system validation report | Components work together as a breadboard, preliminary FMEA or risk analysis |
| 5 | Laboratory-scale prototype validation report | Realistic interfaces, assembly needs assessed, value analysis with life-cycle cost |
| 6 | Engineering/pilot-scale prototype demonstration report | Engineering feasibility shown, critical manufacturing processes prototyped, transition plan with business case |
| 7 | Full-scale system prototype demonstration report | Fully integrated prototype demonstrated in an actual or simulated operational environment, safety issues identified and mitigated |
| 8 | Limited operational environment testing report | Form, fit and function shown in operational environment, acceptable manufacturing yield |
| 9 | Operational environment testing report | Operational test and evaluation completed, design stable, documentation complete |

Notice how early commercial thinking appears: a rough idea of how to market the technology at TRL 2, life-cycle cost at TRL 5, a business case at TRL 6. For guidance on assembling these documents into a pack a reviewer can check, see [how to prove your TRL](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/trl-evidence).

## Sector annexures: healthcare, pharma and software

NTRAF does not split into separate scales. Section 5 says the sector criteria "must be assessed in addition to the general TRL criteria".

**Annexure A, healthcare and pharmaceuticals,** ties levels to regulatory and clinical milestones. Non-GLP toxicity studies and non-GMP lab-scale product appear at TRL 4, DCGI approval for a Phase 1 trial at TRL 5, Phase 1 trials and GMP pilot lots at TRL 6, completed Phase II trials at TRL 7, DCGI approval of the New Drug Application at TRL 8, and commercial launch at TRL 9.

**Annexure B, software,** uses development practice instead: alpha testing and integration with existing systems at TRL 5, beta testing at TRL 6, independent third-party verification at TRL 7, quality assessed against ISO/IEC 9126 or equivalent at TRL 8, and long-term maintenance plans at TRL 9. Annexure C holds definitions.

## Who uses NTRAF?

The document addresses funding organisations and research institutes in India. It proposes that a funded project states its initial and final desired TRLs in the proposal, with a TRL progression timeline approved at fund approval, and that TRL progress becomes a review parameter alongside technical and financial reviews. The "TRA owner" starts the assessment, and is told to begin early because it can take several weeks.

The PSA page adds the intended roles: researchers self-assess, reviewers validate through a standardised digital interface, and policymakers get analytics on translation bottlenecks and funding gaps. It says a future online TRL assessment tool will use the framework as its logic base. Whether a particular funder already applies NTRAF varies by scheme, so read the call document.

## How to self-assess against NTRAF

1. Download the current PSA document, including the annexure for your sector.
2. List your CTEs. A diagnostic might have an assay, a reader and software, and each gets its own assessment.
3. Score Level 0 honestly and note the band.
4. Answer Level 1 with the report in hand. If the report does not exist yet, the answer is no.
5. Work through Level 2 from one level below, marking every critical item with the document that proves it.
6. Write the TRA report. Section 6.1 asks for the assessed TRL and rationale, the planned progression, where you fall short and how you will close the gap, and the risk to cost, schedule and performance.

A second, independent reading helps before a reviewer sees it. [TRL Pro](https://app.zernyxhub.com/trl-calculator) is one option: you enter your technology and get back a readiness level from TRL 1 to 9, assessed with Zernyx's own copyrighted framework (ZTRAF) across more than 60 technology domains and subdomains. ZTRAF is separate from NTRAF, so treat it as a cross-check.

## Common mistakes

Two errors are easy to make. Teams quote the Level 1 answer as their final TRL, when it is the Anticipated TRL until Level 2 confirms it. And they skip the commercial criteria in the evidence table, though a missed critical item drops the level just as a failed test would.

## Common questions

### Is NTRAF mandatory for grant applications in India?

The published document does not make it mandatory. It calls itself an initial proposal of guidelines for funding organisations and research institutes, and PSA's page still invites comments on the draft. Use NTRAF where a funder asks for it, and otherwise follow the funder's own TRL definitions.

### What happens if one NTRAF critical criterion is not met?

The technology cannot be classified at that TRL and is pegged at the next lower level (TRL n-1). The same applies when the supporting document for a critical item is missing.

### Does NTRAF have separate scales for pharma and software?

No. It has one core framework of nine levels, plus Annexure A (healthcare and pharmaceuticals) and Annexure B (software), whose questions are assessed in addition to the general criteria.

### What is a Critical Technology Element in NTRAF?

A technology element that is new or novel and critical to the success of the project. A typical project has several, and NTRAF asks for a separate TRL assessment of each one.

---

Published by Zernyx Hub. More: https://zernyxhub.com/llms.txt
