GuideTechnology transfer

NAAC and IPR: the patent and licensing evidence a university must keep

NAAC IPR evidence for Indian universities: the patent, IPR cell and licensing records to keep, how DVV checks them, and a register that also serves NIRF.

By Dr. Deepak Chitkara, Founder, Zernyx Innovations 7 min read
Short answer

For NAAC, a university's IPR evidence sits in Criterion 3. Universities report patents published or awarded year by year over the last five years, with e-copies of publication or grant letters, and describe their innovation ecosystem, including the IPR cell. DVV verification can drop patents without proof. Keep a register linking each patent to its IP India record.

Every few years an IQAC office asks the IPR cell the same question: how many patents did we publish and get granted, year by year, and where is the proof? If the answer takes three weeks of email to faculty, the problem is not NAAC. It is that the evidence was never kept in one place.

This checklist is for university IPR cells, TTO staff and IQAC coordinators. It covers which NAAC metrics touch IPR, what proof each needs, how verification treats weak evidence, and the register that answers NAAC, NIRF and your own governing body from the same data.

Where does IPR show up in NAAC?

IPR evidence sits in Criterion 3, Research, Innovations and Extension, of NAAC's Revised Accreditation Framework. Two metrics matter most, and the wording below is taken from institutions' published self-study and AQAR reports, because the manual on naac.gov.in could not be opened when this was written. Check the current manual for your institution type before you prepare data.

Metric (as institutions report it) What it asks Type of evidence
3.3.1 Innovation ecosystem That the institution has created an ecosystem for innovations and Indian Knowledge System (IKS), including awareness about IPR, an IPR cell, an incubation centre and other initiatives for creating and transferring knowledge, with evident outcomes Qualitative: description, policy, events, outcomes
3.4.3 Patents (universities) Number of patents published or awarded, year-wise, over the last five years Quantitative: data template plus e-copies of publication or award letters

The patent metric is the one that goes wrong. SRM University's AQAR for 2023-24 shows the format for a single year; the self-study report covers five: a data template listing patents and the year each was awarded, and a file of e-copies of the published patents and award letters. Licensing and technology transfer outcomes have no count of their own in that metric. They belong in the narrative for 3.3.1, as outcomes of the ecosystem, so they need documents too.

How does DVV treat your patent list?

After submission, NAAC's data validation and verification (DVV) stage checks the numbers against the proof. Published DVV responses show what happens to a loose list. HBTU Kanpur's response for 3.4.3 revised its count to include "only the patent granted/published in last five year as instructed in the DVV query", giving 17 patents across five years with proof grouped by department.

Beyond the five-year window, which DVV applies, the reasons a patent may be questioned are dull, and these come from practice rather than NAAC rules:

  • the patent was published or granted outside the five-year window;
  • the applicant is a faculty member alone, with no institutional affiliation shown;
  • the same patent is listed twice, once at publication and once at grant, without a rule for counting;
  • the proof is a filing receipt, which shows filing, not publication or grant;
  • the department cannot find the document at all.

Each is preventable with a register kept as patents move, not assembled before the visit.

One patent through NAAC verification

Patent entry in the SSRCounted
Register entryNumber, dates, applicant, inventors
Proof attachedJournal page or grant certificate
Window checkPublished or granted in five years
DVV reviewClaim matched to proof

What should the IPR register hold?

One row per application, updated at each stage. These columns cover NAAC, NIRF and internal reporting without re-collecting anything.

Column Why you need it Where it comes from
Application number and filing date Every deadline runs from it Filing receipt
Applicant name as filed Shows the institution is applicant or co-applicant Form 1
Inventors and departments Department-wise reporting and inventor shares Form 5, invention disclosure
Publication date and journal issue Counts as "published" IP India Official Journal
Grant date and patent number Counts as "awarded" Grant certificate, e-register
Status and next fee date Avoids lapses that later embarrass the count IP India e-register
Licence or assignment, date and licensee Evidence for innovation outcomes Signed agreement, Form 16 if registered
Licensing income received Outcomes, and royalty distribution Accounts
Form 27 filing dates Statutory compliance Form 27 acknowledgement

Keep the proof file next to the row: the journal page as a PDF, the grant certificate, the signed licence. A link to the IP India record is useful, but download the document too, since links change.

For licences, remember what makes them valid. A licence is valid when it is in writing, with all its terms, and duly executed, under Section 68 of the Patents Act. Registering it under Section 69 on Form 16 is not a condition of validity, though an unregistered document is generally not admitted as evidence of title under Section 69(5). For NAAC, the signed agreement is your evidence. Registration simply makes the public record match it.

A worked example: what a weak register costs

The figures below are an illustration with invented numbers. A university's departments report 40 patents for its five-year window. The IPR cell checks each one before submission.

Check Patents removed Remaining
Reported by departments 40
Filed but not yet published 9 31
Published or granted outside the five-year window 4 27
Faculty filed personally; institution not applicant 5 22
Counted twice (publication and grant) 3 19
No proof document found 2 17

Seventeen counted out of forty reported. The real loss is the last two rows: a patent that exists, inside the window, which the university cannot prove. A register kept as patents move would have saved both. The rule for publication and grant also needs to be settled once and written down, for example by counting a patent in the year of its first qualifying event, and then followed every year.

Forty reported patents in the example

40 patents reported by departments
42%23%13%12%
Counted17 with proof, in window42%
Not yet published9 filed only23%
Out of window410%
Not institutional513%
Duplicate or no proof512%

How does this connect with NIRF?

The same register serves the National Institutional Ranking Framework. NIRF's engineering framework for 2019, for example, gave patents up to 15 marks under Research and Professional Practice: up to 10 for patents granted and up to 5 for patents published, each over the previous three years, from third-party sources. NIRF's windows and weights differ from NAAC's and change between editions, so keep the dates in the register and filter for each report. Do not keep two lists.

What is changing in NAAC?

NAAC is moving to a new system. The Government told the Lok Sabha on 8 December 2025 that the reforms run in two phases: basic or binary accreditation, followed by maturity-based graded levels, with institutions expected to aim for the highest level over 15 years. The new metrics were not confirmed when this was written, so treat any specific number as provisional.

The advice for IPR cells is the same either way. Accreditation frameworks change every few years; patent records do not. A university that can answer "show me every patent, its status and its proof" in an afternoon will do well under any version of the metric.

Common mistakes

  • Treating NAAC as a once-in-five-years project. The register should change every time a patent moves.
  • Letting faculty file in their own names. Your IP policy should say who files, and the IPR cell should check it.
  • Counting outcomes without documents. A licence signed over email, with no executed agreement, is weak evidence and a weak licence.
  • Losing the money trail. Record licensing income as it arrives, then distribute it as your policy says. See distributing licensing income.
  • Missing renewals. A patent that lapses for an unpaid fee is a poor story to tell a peer team, and the status column should have flagged it. See patent renewal for universities.

If you are building the cell itself, start with how to set up an IPR cell, then IP management software for universities for when the spreadsheet stops coping.

Zernyx IPMS is an IP lifecycle management platform for universities and research institutions, to manage patents, filings and IP portfolios end to end. It is one way to keep this register as a working record rather than a once-a-cycle exercise. See Zernyx IPMS.

Common questions

Which NAAC metric counts patents?

Under NAAC's current Revised Accreditation Framework, universities report patents in Criterion 3. Published self-study and AQAR reports show metric 3.4.3, the number of patents published or awarded, with year-wise totals over the last five years and e-copies of publication or award letters. Check the current manual for your institution type before you prepare data.

Does NAAC count patent applications that are only filed?

The patent metric universities publish counts patents published or awarded, not applications merely filed. A filed application usually becomes published about 18 months after its priority date, so it may count in a later year. Record filing dates anyway: you need them for every later deadline.

What does NAAC's DVV ask for on patents?

DVV, the data validation and verification stage, checks each claimed patent against proof. Universities' published DVV responses show lists revised to keep only patents published or granted within the last five years, with proof grouped by department. A patent you cannot document is a patent you lose from the count.

Is NAAC changing how it assesses research and IPR?

Yes. The Government told the Lok Sabha on 8 December 2025 that NAAC is rolling out reforms in two phases: basic or binary accreditation first, then maturity-based graded levels. The final metric wording was not confirmed when this was written. The underlying records you keep stay the same.

Dr. Deepak Chitkara
About the author

Dr. Deepak Chitkara

Founder, Zernyx Innovations

Connect on LinkedInWatch on YouTube
More about Dr. Deepak Chitkara
  • Professor, Department of Pharmacy, BITS Pilani.
  • Has coordinated the Intellectual Property Enablement and Commercialization (IPEC) division at BITS Pilani.
  • Has served as Coordinator of the BITS-Technology Enabling Center, supported by the Department of Science and Technology (DST), Government of India.

Manage every patent in one place.

Zernyx IPMS is an IP management system to manage patents, filings and IP portfolios end to end.

Explore Zernyx IPMS

Keep reading

Looking for something else?