JournalTechnology transfer

MoU or license agreement: what a university should sign with a company

MoU vs agreement for Indian universities: what an MoU can and cannot do, why a patent licence must meet section 68, and which document fits each deal stage.

By Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP 6 min read
Short answer

A memorandum of understanding (MoU) records an intention to cooperate; a licence agreement grants rights to use IP for payment. An MoU rarely meets the bar for a patent licence. Section 68 of the Patents Act, 1970 makes a licence valid only if it is in writing, sets out all its terms and is duly executed.

Indian universities sign a great many MoUs. They are announced at events, photographed and counted in accreditation reports. Some lead to real work. Many lead to nothing, and a few cause problems because one side thought it had rights the document never actually gave.

The confusion is usually about what an MoU can do. It is good at expressing goodwill and setting up a framework. It is poor at granting intellectual property rights, and for patents the law sets a specific bar. This post explains the difference between an MoU and a licence agreement, the documents that sit between them, and how an IPR cell should decide which to sign.

What is the difference between an MoU and a licence agreement?

Point MoU Licence agreement
Purpose Record an intention to cooperate Grant the right to use specific IP
Typical content Areas of interest, contacts, joint activities, review meetings Licensed IP, field, territory, exclusivity, fees, royalty, diligence, reporting, warranties, termination
Binding? Often stated as non-binding, except confidentiality and similar clauses Binding contract
Money Usually none, or "to be agreed" Upfront fee, royalty, milestones
IP rights Usually none, or a promise to discuss Defined grant of rights
Legal test for patents Rarely meets section 68 Must meet section 68
Registration Not registered Licensee or licensor may apply to register under section 69

Section 68 of the Patents Act, 1970 is the line. A licence of a patent is not valid unless it is in writing, the agreement between the parties is reduced to a document embodying all its terms and conditions, and the document is duly executed. An MoU that leaves terms "to be mutually agreed" falls short by design.

Registration is a separate step. Under section 69, the licensee or the licensor applies to the Controller to register the licence. Registration is not a condition of validity. Still, an unregistered document is not admitted as evidence of title unless the Controller or court directs otherwise.

MoU or licence agreement

MoU
Intention to cooperate
Usually non-binding
No IP rights granted
vs
Licence agreement
Grant of defined rights
Binding, with fees
Must meet section 68

Use the MoU to open the door; use the licence to transfer rights.

Which documents sit between an MoU and a licence?

A technology deal usually moves through several documents, each doing one job:

Stage Document What it does
First contact MoU, if both sides want one Sets the relationship and areas of interest
Sharing confidential information Non-disclosure agreement Protects unpublished data and inventions
Sharing samples or materials Material transfer agreement Controls use of materials and results
Joint or funded research Sponsored research or collaboration agreement Sets work, funding, publication and ownership of results
Evaluation Option agreement Gives the company time to evaluate, with a right to negotiate a licence
Commercial use Licence agreement Grants rights for payment
Know-how and support Technology transfer agreement, if separate Covers data, training and support

Institutional IP policies often require some of these steps. The AIIMS IPR Policy 2017, for example, requires an NDA or MTA before confidential information or research material is shared, and a signed technology transfer or licence agreement before a third party uses the technology. Check what your own policy requires.

Ownership of results from joint work is the point most often fudged. If an MoU says results will be "jointly owned" without saying who files, who pays and who may license, both parties will struggle to commercialise later. Settle it in the research agreement; sponsored research agreement covers the clauses.

When is an MoU the right document?

An MoU is useful when:

  • The relationship is new and both sides want a framework before committing money.
  • The activities are broad: internships, guest lectures, lab visits, joint events.
  • A government programme or accreditation process asks for a record of collaboration.
  • Several departments will work with the same company on different projects.

It is the wrong document when:

  • The company wants to use a patent or know-how commercially.
  • Money will change hands for IP.
  • Either side will rely on exclusivity.
  • The university needs to enforce obligations such as diligence or reporting.

What should an IPR cell check in an MoU?

Even a non-binding MoU can create risk. Before signing, check:

  1. That it says clearly which clauses bind and which do not.
  2. That it grants no IP rights, or says any rights will be granted only in a separate written agreement.
  3. That confidentiality applies from the start, or that an NDA will be signed before data is shared.
  4. That it does not promise exclusivity or a right of first refusal on future inventions without the IPR cell's review.
  5. That publication rights for faculty and students are preserved.
  6. That it has an end date or a review date.

Point 4 matters most. A sentence such as "the company will have first right to commercialise inventions arising from the collaboration" can tie up a whole department's future work. If a first right is intended, define it in a research agreement, with a time limit.

From MoU to licence

1
MoUFramework, no IP rights
2
NDA or MTABefore data or samples move
3
Research or option agreementOwnership of results settled
4
Licence agreementAll terms, signed: section 68
5
Register the licenceSection 69, evidence of title

A worked example

Illustration with invented details. A university signs an MoU with a Pune auto-components company for "collaboration in materials research and technology transfer". A year later, a faculty member's patented coating interests the company.

Step What happened What should have happened
MoU clause "Technologies developed shall be made available to the company on preferential terms" "Any licence of IP shall be agreed in a separate written agreement"
Data sharing Coating data sent by email after the MoU NDA signed first
Licence Company argues the MoU already gives it preferential rights; months lost Option, then licence with fee and royalty
Result Deal delayed; terms weaker for the university Clear rights, agreed price

Under a licence with a ₹10 lakh upfront fee and 3% royalty on ₹2 crore of annual sales, the university would earn ₹16 lakh in the first year. A vague MoU clause that forces a discount of even one percentage point costs it ₹2 lakh a year in royalty.

Common mistakes

  • Treating an MoU as permission to use a patent.
  • Promising exclusive or preferential rights in an MoU without IPR cell review.
  • Sharing confidential data under an MoU with no confidentiality clause.
  • Leaving ownership of joint results to "mutual agreement".
  • Counting MoUs as outcomes. Licences, research income and products are the outcomes.

My view: an IPR cell should review every MoU that mentions IP, technology transfer or inventions, however routine it looks. Whether a particular MoU clause binds is a question of wording and intention, and I would not give a general answer on that; take legal advice on any clause you are unsure about.

Zernyx IPMS is an IP lifecycle management platform for universities and research institutions, to manage patents, filings and IP portfolios end to end. For marketing technologies once the paperwork is clear, see marketing university technologies.

Common questions

Is an MoU legally binding in India?

It depends on the wording and on what the parties intended. Many MoUs say expressly that they are not binding except for clauses such as confidentiality. Others contain firm obligations and can be enforced like a contract. Read each clause, and state clearly which parts bind and which do not.

Can an MoU license a university's patent?

Not safely. Section 68 of the Patents Act, 1970 says a licence is not valid unless it is in writing, the agreement is reduced to a document embodying all its terms and conditions, and it is duly executed. A general MoU that leaves fees, field and territory to be agreed later does not meet that test.

When should a university sign an MoU with a company?

When the two sides want to signal a relationship and set up a framework for joint activities such as student projects, visits, joint events or future research, with the specific obligations left to later agreements. It is a good start, not a substitute for those agreements.

What documents follow an MoU in a technology deal?

Usually a non-disclosure agreement before confidential data is shared, a material transfer agreement if samples move, a sponsored research or collaboration agreement for joint work, an option if the company wants time to evaluate, and finally a licence agreement, with or without a separate technology transfer agreement.

Sahil Sheikh
About the author

Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP

Chief IP & Technology Officer, Zernyx Innovations

Connect on LinkedIn

Manage every patent in one place.

Zernyx IPMS is an IP management system to manage patents, filings and IP portfolios end to end.

Explore Zernyx IPMS

Keep reading

Looking for something else?