# Licensing or reverse engineering: cost, time and legal risk for MSMEs

URL: https://zernyxhub.com/blog/licensing-vs-reverse-engineering
Author: Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP
Published: 2026-11-05
Category: Licensing

> Is reverse engineering legal in India? What the Patents Act and Copyright Act allow, when a licence is cheaper, and a decision table for MSMEs.

**Short answer:** Reverse engineering a product you lawfully bought is legal in India when no IP right covers it. If the product or its process is patented, making or selling a copy without consent infringes under section 48 of the Patents Act, 1970. Section 47(3) only allows experiment or research use. For patented technology, a licence is the safer route.

Many MSME owners have had the thought at least once: buy the competitor's machine, open it up, and make our own. Sometimes that is perfectly legal and sensible. Sometimes it ends with a court injunction, a stock of seized goods and a royalty bill bigger than a licence would ever have cost.

The difference is almost never about the engineering. It is about what is protected inside the product, and whether you checked before you started. This post sets out what Indian law allows, what each route really costs in time and money, and a decision table you can use before your team picks up a screwdriver.

This is general guidance. A patent agent or lawyer should look at the specific product before you commit money.

## Is reverse engineering legal in India?

There is no Indian statute that bans reverse engineering as such. Buying a product and studying how it works is, in most cases, lawful. The legal question is what you do next, and that depends on which rights cover the product.

| What protects the product | What the law allows | Where the risk is |
|---|---|---|
| Nothing (no patent, design or copyright in force) | Study, copy and sell | Low; check for expired or lapsed rights first |
| An Indian patent in force on the product | Experiment and research only, under section 47(3) | Making, using, selling or importing for sale infringes under section 48(a) |
| An Indian patent on the process | Study the product; use a different process | Using the process, or selling its direct product, infringes under section 48(b) |
| Copyright in software | Interoperability and study under section 52(1)(ab) and (ac) of the Copyright Act | Copying or adapting the code for a competing product |
| Know-how kept confidential | Learn it from the product you bought | Taking it from a former employee or a partner under an NDA |

Section 48 of the [Patents Act, 1970](https://ipindia.gov.in/acts/patent-act-1970/section-48) gives a product patentee the exclusive right to prevent others, without consent, from making, using, offering for sale, selling or importing the product in India. For a process patent it covers using the process and selling the product obtained directly by it.

[Section 47(3)](https://ipindia.gov.in/acts/patent-act-1970/section-47) is the research exception. Anyone may make or use a patented invention "for the purpose merely of experiment or research including the imparting of instructions to pupils." That lets your engineers study a patented machine. It does not let you sell the copy.

A trade secret is different. India has no separate trade secret statute; confidential know-how is protected by contracts and by the law of confidence. Learning something honestly from a product you bought is generally fair. Getting it from a former employee of the owner, or from a partner who signed an NDA, is where cases begin.

**Two routes to the same product**
Reverse engineering:
- No fee to the owner
- Months of teardown and trials
- You carry the infringement risk
- No know-how or training
Licensing:
- Upfront fee and royalty
- Know-how and support can be included
- Written right to make and sell
- Faster to a validated product
If a patent in force covers it, licensing is the safer route.

## What does each route cost in time and money?

Teams usually compare a licence fee with "free". That comparison is wrong. Reverse engineering has its own costs, and most of them sit in salaries and lost months.

| Cost line | Reverse engineering | Licensing |
|---|---|---|
| Payment to the technology owner | None | Upfront fee plus royalty, as negotiated |
| Engineering time | Teardown, drawings, material analysis, trial batches | Absorbing the transferred documents and training |
| Patent search | Freedom-to-operate search is essential | Due diligence on the licensed patent |
| Process know-how | Rebuilt by trial and error | Usually included in a know-how licence |
| Legal exposure | Injunction, damages, seizure if a patent is infringed | Contract risk only, if you follow the terms |
| Time to first saleable batch | Often the longest line in the plan | Often shorter, because the owner has solved the hard parts |

The law on remedies is plain. [Section 108](https://ipindia.gov.in/acts/patent-act-1970/section-108) lets a court grant an injunction and, at the patentee's option, damages or an account of profits. It can also order infringing goods, and the materials and tools used mainly to make them, to be seized, forfeited or destroyed, with no compensation.

Process patents carry an extra trap for anyone who copies a chemical or biological product. Under [section 104A](https://ipindia.gov.in/acts/patent-act-1970/section-104a), once the patentee proves your product is identical to the one made directly by the patented process, the court can ask you to prove your process is different. That applies where the patent is for a process of obtaining a new product, or where the identical product was probably made by the patented process and the patentee could not find out, despite reasonable efforts, which process you used. If your team rebuilt the process by working backwards from the product, that is an uncomfortable position.

## A worked example in rupees

**Illustration with invented figures.** An MSME making food processing equipment wants to add a patented drying unit to its range. It weighs both routes over the first two years.

| Item | Reverse engineering | Licensing |
|---|---|---|
| Teardown, drawings and trials (two engineers, nine months) | ₹27,00,000 | Not needed |
| Absorbing transferred drawings and training (two engineers, three months) | Not needed | ₹9,00,000 |
| Freedom-to-operate search and opinion | ₹1,50,000 | Not needed |
| Due diligence on the licensed patent | Not needed | ₹75,000 |
| Upfront licence fee | None | ₹8,00,000 |
| Royalty at 3% on two years' net sales of ₹1.5 crore | None | ₹4,50,000 |
| Total in two years | ₹28,50,000 | ₹22,25,000 |
| Months before first sale | About 12 | About 4 |

In this example the search comes back with a bad answer: the drying unit is covered by an Indian patent with eleven years left. The reverse engineering column then stops being an option at all, unless the team designs around the claims. The ₹28.5 lakh is already partly spent.

Your numbers will differ. The table makes one point that holds well beyond its invented numbers: the in-house route often costs more than it looks, because engineering months are rarely priced honestly. For how a licence fee is usually built, see [cost to license a technology in India](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/cost-to-license-technology-india).

## How do you decide? A step-by-step check

Run this before any teardown that is meant to lead to production.

**Before you open the product up**
1. Identify the rights: Patents, designs, software copyright, NDAs
2. Check status in India: In force, lapsed or expired, on IP India's search
3. Read the claims: Does your planned product fall inside them?
4. Price both routes: Engineering months, fees, royalty, delay
5. Decide and document: Licence, design around, or copy what is free

1. **List every right that might cover the product.** Look at patent markings, the manufacturer's patent filings, registered designs and any software. Our guide to [finding a licensor from a patent](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/find-licensor-from-patent) shows how to trace the owner.
2. **Check the status of each in India.** A patent granted abroad gives no rights in India unless an Indian patent exists. A lapsed or expired Indian patent is open for use; see [are expired patents free to use?](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/expired-patents-free-to-use).
3. **Read the claims, not the abstract.** Infringement depends on the claims. [How to read patent claims](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/read-patent-claims) walks through it.
4. **Price both routes honestly**, using engineering months at real cost.
5. **Decide, and keep a written record** of what you checked and when. If a dispute comes later, that file is your first defence.

For anything close to a live patent, get a proper [freedom-to-operate](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/freedom-to-operate-india) opinion before you invest.

## When does reverse engineering make sense?

It makes sense when the product is old, the patents have expired or lapsed, and the value lies in your own manufacturing skill. It also makes sense for interoperability work in software, where section 52(1)(ab) of the Copyright Act, 1957 allows a lawful possessor to obtain information essential for making an independent program work with it, if that information is not otherwise readily available.

It makes less sense when a patent in force covers the core, when the process is the hard part (common in chemicals, food and biotech), or when the owner holds know-how you cannot see from the finished product. In those cases you are paying to rediscover what a licence would hand you.

## Common mistakes

- Treating a foreign patent number on the product as an Indian right, or ignoring an Indian patent because the product was imported.
- Assuming the research exception covers pilot batches sold to "friendly" customers. It does not.
- Hiring the competitor's engineer and calling the result reverse engineering.
- Ignoring the process. A product can be unpatented while the cheapest way to make it is patented.
- Never asking the owner. Many patent holders, including public institutes, would rather license than litigate.

My view: for an MSME, a written licence is usually the better use of money whenever a live Indian patent covers the core of the product. I cannot give a rule for every case, because the answer depends on the claims, the remaining patent term and what the owner will accept.

If you would rather start from technologies that are already on offer, [Zernyx Hub](https://www.zernyxhub.com) has mapped patents from universities across India, with AI business insight on each, including its commercial applications.

## Common questions

### Is reverse engineering legal in India?

Taking apart and studying a product you lawfully own is generally lawful. The risk starts when you make or sell what you learnt. If the product or process is under an Indian patent in force, section 48 of the Patents Act lets the patentee stop you from making, using, selling or importing it without consent.

### Can I reverse engineer a patented product for research?

Yes, within limits. Section 47(3) of the Patents Act allows a patented product or process to be made or used merely for experiment or research, including teaching. It does not cover commercial production. Once you start making for sale, you need a licence or a design that avoids the claims.

### Is it legal to reverse engineer software in India?

Partly. Section 52(1)(ab) of the Copyright Act, 1957 allows a lawful possessor to do what is needed to obtain information essential for interoperability, if it is not otherwise readily available. Section 52(1)(ac) allows observing and testing a program to learn its underlying ideas. Copying the code itself is still infringement.

### What happens if a reverse engineered product infringes a patent?

Under section 108 of the Patents Act, a court can grant an injunction, damages or an account of profits, and order infringing goods and the tools used mainly to make them to be seized or destroyed. For a process patent, section 104A can shift the burden of proof to you.

---

Published by Zernyx Hub. More: https://zernyxhub.com/llms.txt
