# IP valuation for MSMEs in India: when you need one and what it costs

URL: https://zernyxhub.com/blog/ip-valuation-for-msme
Author: Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP
Published: 2026-10-27
Category: Licensing

> IP valuation in India for MSMEs: when the law or a lender needs one, the cost, market and income approaches, IBBI registered valuers and what drives the fee.

**Short answer:** IP valuation in India estimates what a patent, trademark or other IP is worth for one stated purpose. An MSME may need one for licensing, fundraising, IP-backed loans, mergers, transfer pricing or insolvency. Valuations required under the Companies Act, 2013 or the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 must be done by an IBBI registered valuer. Fees vary with scope.

An IP valuation is a number attached to a purpose. The same patent can carry one value for a bank, another in a merger and a third across a licensing table, and all three can be defensible. So the first question for an MSME is why the number is needed and who will rely on it. That decides whether the law requires a registered valuer, which approach fits and what the report will cost.

This article covers the situations, the three approaches, who may sign, what drives the fee and what to prepare. For worked numbers on a single patent, see our guide on [how to value a patent for an Indian startup](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/patent-valuation-for-startups).

## When does an MSME need an IP valuation?

Some triggers are set by law. Others are set by whoever is across the table.

| Situation | What triggers the valuation | Registered valuer required? |
|---|---|---|
| Licensing IP in or out | Your negotiation, or the other side's request | No, a commercial choice |
| Preferential issue of shares, including shares issued for IP | Section 62(1)(c), Companies Act, 2013 | Yes |
| Non-cash transaction with a director | Section 192, Companies Act, 2013 | Yes |
| Merger, demerger or scheme of arrangement | Sections 230 and 232, Companies Act, 2013 | Yes |
| IP-backed loan | The lender's credit policy | The lender decides |
| Licence with a foreign group company | Arm's length price, Section 165, Income-tax Act, 2025 | Arm's length analysis needed |
| Corporate insolvency or liquidation | IBBI regulations under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 | Yes |

The "Yes" rows come from IBBI's [circular IBBI/RVO/026/2019](https://www.ibbi.gov.in/uploads/legalframwork/fc079317863706b25d7d688d3596c327.pdf) of 16 September 2019, which lists the provisions of the Companies Act and the Code that need a registered valuer.

### Licensing in or out

For a voluntary licence between unrelated companies, a valuation is your own decision. You still want a number before the other side names one. Our guides on [putting a price on a technology](https://zernyxhub.com/academy#value-tech) and [royalty rates](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/royalty-rates) cover the negotiation, and [what it costs to license a technology in India](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/cost-to-license-technology-india) lists fees that public institutions publish. In practice a short internal note is enough here. A formal report earns its fee only when a board, an investor or a lender will read it.

### Fundraising

[Section 62(1)(c)](https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/w/section-62-101) allows a company to issue shares to any persons, for cash or for consideration other than cash, only if they are authorised by a special resolution and the price is determined by a registered valuer's report. That report values the shares, and the IP sits inside it. If a founder or a partner company contributes IP in exchange for shares, the IP is the consideration, so the valuer will need a defensible value for it.

### IP-backed loans

[Section 68](https://ipindia.gov.in/acts/patent-act-1970/section-68) of the Patents Act, 1970 covers a mortgage of a patent: it must be in writing, with all terms in one document. Section 69 lets the mortgagee register its interest, and the mortgagor may apply too, on Form 16. The [First Schedule](https://www.ipindia.gov.in/writereaddata/Portal/ev/schedules/Schedule_1.pdf) fee is per patent and follows the applicant.

**Illustration.** An MSME offers three granted patents as security. If the bank files Form 16 itself, it pays the "others" rate online: 3 × ₹8,000 = ₹24,000. If the MSME files alone and qualifies as a small entity, it pays 3 × ₹1,600 = ₹4,800. Either way, confirm the renewals first, since a patent ceases under Section 53 if the renewal fee is not paid.

The National IPR Policy, 2016 named the valuation of IP as a constraint on commercialisation, and its step 5.11.1 lists enabling the valuation of IP rights as intangible assets and their use as collateral. Whether your bank accepts a patent as security, and on whose valuation, remains its credit decision. Ask before you commission anything.

### Mergers and director transactions

The IBBI circular lists Sections 230 and 232 (compromises, arrangements, mergers and amalgamations) and Section 192 (non-cash transactions involving directors) among the provisions that need a registered valuer. A founder who holds a patent personally and moves it into the company should ask early whether Section 192 or Section 62 applies.

### Transfer pricing

If you license IP to or from an associated enterprise abroad, the royalty must be at arm's length. [Section 165](https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/w/section-165-81) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 names six methods: comparable uncontrolled price, resale price, cost plus, profit split, transactional net margin, and any other method the Board prescribes. The most appropriate one applies. [Rule 79](https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/w/rule-79-3) of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 describes the profit split method, which may be applicable mainly to transactions involving the transfer of unique intangibles. Your tax adviser leads here.

### Insolvency

In a corporate insolvency resolution process, regulation 27 of IBBI's CIRP Regulations, 2016 requires the resolution professional to appoint registered valuers to determine the fair value and liquidation value of the company. The IP is part of those assets. IBBI has amended the regulation more than once; under its [May 2026 amendment](https://ibbi.gov.in/uploads/legalframwork/6b5abb77c7b6270e12e92824f2d15c37.pdf), a corporate debtor that is an MSME gets one set of registered valuers unless the committee of creditors records reasons for two.

## What are the three approaches to valuing IP?

Every valuation uses one or more of three approaches. IBBI's [2026 syllabus](https://ibbi.gov.in/uploads/exams/2026Syllabus-SFA.pdf) for the Securities or Financial Assets class names the methods under each, including five specifically for intangibles: excess earnings, relief from royalty, premium profit, greenfield and distributor.

| Approach | The question it asks | Methods named by IBBI | Suits | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cost | What would it cost to recreate or replace the IP? | Replacement cost, net asset value, adjusted value | Early IP with no sales | Cost says nothing about earnings |
| Market | What have buyers paid for similar IP? | Price of recent transaction or investment | IP with public comparable deals | Deal terms are often confidential |
| Income | What will the IP earn, and what is that worth today? | Discounted cash flow; relief from royalty, excess earnings, premium profit, greenfield and distributor methods for intangibles | IP behind a product with a forecast | Sensitive to royalty rate, life and discount rate |

Chartered accountants follow the [ICAI Valuation Standards 2018](https://www.icai.org/post/15070), including VS 103 on valuation approaches and methods and VS 302 on intangible assets, for reports issued on or after 1 July 2018. The same syllabus lists the International Valuation Standards as updated in January 2025.

One opinion, held firmly: ask the valuer to run at least two approaches and explain the weighting in writing. A single-method number is hard to defend when a bank or a buyer challenges it. The relief-from-royalty method also depends on a royalty rate, so read our [royalty rates](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/royalty-rates) guide before you accept one.

## Who can value IP in India?

Under Section 247 of the Companies Act, 2013 and the Companies (Registered Valuers and Valuation) Rules, 2017, valuations required by the Act go to registered valuers. IBBI's [FAQ for valuers](https://ibbi.gov.in/uploads/faqs/FAQsforRegistrationasaValuer-Individual-01October2021.pdf) says that from 1 February 2019 only registered valuers can undertake valuations under the Companies Act and the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code.

IBBI registers valuers in three asset classes: Land and Building, Plant and Machinery, and Securities or Financial Assets. IP has no class of its own. The intangibles material sits in the Securities or Financial Assets syllabus, so that is the class to look for, and you should still ask about the valuer's IP experience. To register, a valuer must be a member of a registered valuers organisation, complete a 50-hour course for the class and pass IBBI's valuation examination.

Verify before you hire. IBBI's [register of individual registered valuers](https://ibbi.gov.in/service-provider/rvs) shows each valuer's registration number, organisation, date of registration and asset class, and can be filtered by asset class. It listed 6,345 records on 27 October 2026. Entities are listed separately.

For a valuation no law requires, anyone competent can do it. If a bank, an investor or a court will rely on the report, hire a registered valuer anyway. It removes one line of attack.

**Who decides how the valuation is done?**
The law decides:
- Companies Act or IBC requires it
- An IBBI registered valuer signs
- Report contents set by Rule 8(3)
- No success fee
You decide:
- Licensing or internal planning
- Any competent valuer
- Scope agreed with you
- A short note can be enough
If anyone outside the company will rely on it, treat it as statutory.

## What drives the price of a valuation report?

There is no official fee scale for IP valuation reports. What the rules do say is how fees are charged. The [Model Code of Conduct](https://ibbi.gov.in/webadmin/pdf/legalframwork/2018/Jun/The%20Companies%20%28Registered%20Valuers%20and%20Valuation%29%20Rules,%202017_2018-06-22%2012:53:39.pdf) in Annexure-I to the 2017 Rules says a registered valuer shall not charge a success fee, must charge remuneration transparently as a reasonable reflection of the work, and may not accept fees beyond those disclosed in a written contract. So the price follows the work, and the work depends on:

- The purpose. A statutory report must state everything in Rule 8(3): background on the asset, purpose and appointing authority, the valuer and other experts, any conflict, the dates of appointment, valuation and report, inspections, sources, procedures and standards, restrictions on use, major factors, the conclusion, and caveats, which may not limit the valuer's responsibility.
- The number of assets and countries. One Indian patent is a smaller job than a family filed in five countries plus trademarks.
- The stage. Pre-revenue IP needs scenarios and a probability of success.
- Your data. Product-wise revenue and clean R&D cost records save the valuer days.
- Technical input. Claim scope, readiness and freedom to operate may need a patent agent or a domain expert.
- The deadline, and who will rely on the report.

Fees vary between valuers. Get two written quotes for the same scope and compare what each will actually deliver.

## What documents should an MSME prepare?

A typical engagement runs in six steps: agree the purpose, sign an engagement letter with the fee in writing, send the data pack, answer the valuer's questions during analysis, check the draft for factual errors, and receive the signed report. Have the data pack ready before you sign the letter. Prepare:

1. A list of every IP right: numbers, countries, filing and grant dates, status and the renewal position from the IP India e-register. Legal life matters, since a patent lasts 20 years from filing under Section 53.
2. Chain of title: inventor assignments, employment and consultancy agreements, co-owner agreements.
3. Every licence, option, NDA and recorded mortgage touching the IP.
4. Revenue from products that use the IP, ideally for three years, with forecasts and their assumptions.
5. R&D cost records: people, materials, external testing and filing costs, for the cost approach.
6. Market evidence: competing products, prices and any royalty offers you have received.
7. Technical evidence: test reports, readiness level, regulatory status.

Our [patent due diligence checklist](https://zernyxhub.com/blog/patent-due-diligence) covers the ownership and status checks a valuer will also run.

**How an IP valuation engagement usually runs**
1. Agree the purpose: Who will rely on the number
2. Engagement letter: Scope and fee in writing
3. Send the data pack: Title, revenue, costs, evidence
4. Analysis and questions: Ask for two approaches or more
5. Check the draft: Factual errors only
6. Signed report: Rule 8(3) contents if statutory

If the valuation supports licensing in, the alternatives matter as much as the number. [Zernyx Hub](https://www.zernyxhub.com) has mapped patents from universities across India, and its AI gives business insight on each, including its commercial applications, so you can see what else is available before you defend a price.

## Common questions

### Who can value IP for a company in India?

For valuations required under the Companies Act, 2013 or the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, only a registered valuer, which IBBI says applies from 1 February 2019. IBBI registers valuers in three asset classes, and intangibles sit in the syllabus for Securities or Financial Assets. For a voluntary licensing negotiation, the choice of valuer is yours.

### How much does an IP valuation report cost in India?

There is no published fee scale. The price follows the work: the purpose, the number of assets and countries, the data you can supply and who will rely on the report. IBBI's model code of conduct bars registered valuers from charging a success fee and requires fees to be disclosed in a written contract.

### Can a patent be mortgaged to a bank in India?

Yes. Section 68 of the Patents Act, 1970 covers a mortgage of a patent, which must be in writing with all its terms, and Section 69 provides for registering it on Form 16. The online fee is ₹1,600 per patent for a natural person, startup, small entity or educational institution (with Form 28) and ₹8,000 for others. Whether a lender accepts IP as security is its own credit decision.

### How do I check that a valuer is registered with IBBI?

Search the register of individual registered valuers on ibbi.gov.in by name, registration number, location or asset class. Each entry shows the registration number, the registered valuers organisation, the date of registration and the asset class. Ask for the registration number before you sign the engagement letter.

### Does a licence with a foreign group company need a valuation?

It needs an arm's length price. Section 165 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 requires the most appropriate of six methods, and Rule 79 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 describes the profit split method, which may be applicable mainly to transactions involving the transfer of unique intangibles. Take your tax adviser's view before you sign.

---

Published by Zernyx Hub. More: https://zernyxhub.com/llms.txt
