GuideTechnology transfer

Conflict of interest in faculty startups: a policy checklist for universities

Conflict of interest policy for universities with faculty startups: what NISP 2019 asks, what to disclose, who decides, and a checklist for an Indian IPR cell.

By Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP 6 min read
Short answer

A university conflict of interest policy for faculty startups sets what founders must disclose, who reviews it and how conflicts are managed. The National Innovation and Startup Policy 2019 asks institutes to develop one so faculty duties are not neglected. AIIMS's IPR Policy 2017, for example, requires disclosure of family stakes in a licensee and approval before licensing.

A professor founds a company on her lab's invention. She is now the inventor, a shareholder, the company's chief scientist, the supervisor of two PhD students who work on the same problem, and a member of the department that buys equipment. None of this is wrong. Indian policy encourages it. But each role pulls a little against the others, and without rules the institution cannot show that its decisions were fair.

A conflict of interest policy does that job. It does not stop faculty startups; it lets them happen in the open. This guide covers what national policy says, what a policy should require, who should decide, and a checklist an IPR cell can use.

What does national policy say?

The National Innovation and Startup Policy 2019 encourages faculty to found and support startups, as an owner or direct promoter, mentor, consultant or board member. On conflicts, it asks institutes to work on developing a policy on conflict of interest, so that faculty duties are not neglected because of startup involvement. It leaves the details to each institute.

Some institutions have written theirs into their IP policy. The AIIMS IPR Policy 2017, for example, requires inventors to disclose actual or potential conflicts, including stakes held by immediate family in a licensee company, and requires approval before licensing to such a company.

Source What it says on conflicts
NISP 2019 Institutes should develop a conflict of interest policy so faculty duties are not neglected
AIIMS IPR Policy 2017 Disclose actual or potential conflicts, including family stakes in a licensee; approval before licensing to such a company

Both leave a lot to the institute. That is where a written policy and a simple process come in. The faculty side of startup rules is covered in starting a company as a faculty member.

What kinds of conflict arise?

Type Example Risk
Financial Founder holds shares in a company licensing institute IP Licence terms favour the company
Time Founder spends working hours on the company Teaching and supervision suffer
Students PhD student works for the supervisor's company Academic progress tied to company needs
Procurement Department buys from the founder's company Purchase decisions questioned
Research Sponsored research from the founder's company to the founder's lab Results or publication shaped by company interest
Information Founder uses confidential institute or sponsor data in the company Breach of confidentiality

A policy should name these types, so faculty can recognise them in their own situation.

What should the policy require?

  1. Annual disclosure by every faculty member with an outside business interest, and fresh disclosure when anything changes.
  2. Disclosure of immediate family interests, as AIIMS's policy does.
  3. A conflict committee that reviews disclosures, with no member who has an interest in the case.
  4. A management plan for each significant conflict: what the person may and may not do, and who oversees it.
  5. Recusal: the conflicted person takes no part in institute decisions about the company, including licences, purchases and student assignments.
  6. Student safeguards: a second supervisor or an independent mentor for students who work for a supervisor's company.
  7. Publication protection: the company cannot block or delay thesis publication beyond an agreed short review period.
  8. Records: disclosures, decisions and management plans kept and reviewed.

Handling a faculty founder's conflict

1
DiscloseRole, shares, family, students
2
ReviewCommittee without the founder
3
Management planWhat they may and may not do
4
RecuseNo part in institute decisions on the company
5
Review yearlyUpdate as the company grows

Who should decide?

The conflict committee should include a senior academic, the head of the IPR cell or TTO, a finance or legal officer and, for student matters, someone from the academic office. The founder may explain but should not vote. For licences to the founder's company, the committee or the competent authority approves the terms after the TTO negotiates them; the founder negotiates only for the company. Licensing IP to a faculty startup covers the licence terms.

Managed conflict or hidden conflict

Managed
Disclosed every year
Founder recused from deals
Students have a second supervisor
vs
Hidden
Discovered later
Licence terms questioned
Students caught in the middle

Disclosure protects the founder as much as the institution.

A worked example

Illustration with invented details and figures. An engineering university licenses a sensor patent to a startup in which a professor holds 40% and her spouse 10%.

Step What the policy requires Outcome
Disclosure Professor discloses her 40% and her spouse's 10% Recorded by the IPR cell
Licence negotiation TTO negotiates; professor represents the company only 2% royalty, ₹1,00,000 upfront fee
Approval Conflict committee reviews terms against comparable licences Approved with a milestone clause
Students One PhD student works part-time for the company Co-supervisor appointed; thesis review limited to 30 days
Procurement Department considers buying the company's sensor Professor recused; purchase committee decides

Two years later, an investor's due diligence asks how the licence was approved. The university produces the disclosure, the committee minutes and the management plan. The round closes without delay.

A disclosure form an IPR cell can use

A short, annual form is enough for most faculty. It should ask:

Question What the answer shows
Do you or your immediate family hold shares or options in any company? Which, and how much? Financial interest
Do you hold any role in a company: founder, director, adviser, consultant? Time and decision interest
Have you received payments from a company in the last 12 months? Consulting or advisory income
Does any company you are linked to hold, or seek, a licence or contract with the institute? Institutional conflict
Do any of your students or staff work for that company? Student conflict
Does the company use institute facilities, equipment or data? Use of resources
Has anything changed since your last disclosure? Keeps the record current

Ask for the form every year and whenever a new licence, contract or purchase involving the company is proposed. Keep it with the IPR cell, not only the department, so the TTO can see it before negotiating.

How do conflict rules fit with royalty sharing?

A faculty founder may receive income in two ways from the same invention: an inventor's share of the institute's royalty under its IP policy, and value as a shareholder in the licensee. Both are legitimate. The policy should say so plainly and require both to be disclosed, so nobody later claims the founder was paid twice without the institute knowing. See faculty royalty sharing for how inventor shares usually work.

Common mistakes

  • No written policy, so every case is decided from scratch.
  • Ignoring family interests.
  • Letting the founder negotiate the licence for the institute.
  • No safeguards for students working in the company.
  • Collecting disclosures once and never updating them.

My view: the student safeguards are the part most often missing, and the part that causes the most harm when they are absent, because students have the least power to object. I am less certain how strictly institutions enforce recusal in small departments where everyone knows each other; a written management plan at least makes the expectation clear.

Conflict records sit alongside the institution's patent records. Zernyx IPMS is an IP lifecycle management platform for universities and research institutions, to manage patents, filings and IP portfolios end to end.

Common questions

Does NISP 2019 require a conflict of interest policy?

It asks institutes to work on developing a policy on conflict of interest, so that faculty duties are not neglected because of startup involvement. It leaves the content to each institute, so policies differ from institute to institute.

What should a faculty founder disclose?

Their role and shareholding in the startup, those of immediate family, any consulting or advisory payments, use of institute facilities, students working for the company, and any licence or contract between the institute and the company. Disclose before the conflict arises and update every year.

Can a faculty founder negotiate the licence with their own startup?

No. The founder sits on the company's side of the deal. The institute should be represented by the IPR cell or TTO and a committee without the founder, which approves the terms. AIIMS's policy requires approval before licensing to a company in which an inventor or family member has a stake.

Can students work in a professor's startup?

They can, with safeguards. The student's academic progress must not depend on work for the company, the supervisor's role must be separated from the employer's, and publication of thesis work must not be blocked by the company's interests.

Sahil Sheikh
About the author

Sahil Sheikh, Regd. Patent & Trademark Agent, cRTTP

Chief IP & Technology Officer, Zernyx Innovations

Connect on LinkedIn

Manage every patent in one place.

Zernyx IPMS is an IP management system to manage patents, filings and IP portfolios end to end.

Explore Zernyx IPMS

Keep reading

Looking for something else?